Patent Trial and Appeal Board May 2021 casesValencell, Inc.KLA-Tencor CorporationHONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL INC.Johnson Controls Technology CompanyTHUMBTACK, INC.Harman International Industries, IncorporatedWELLTEC A/SImmverVision, Inc.Milliken & CompanyTHE TORONTO DOMINION BANKSUBIL ABRAHAM et al.EATON CORPORATIONSecured Mobility, LLCDELTA ELECTRONICS, INC.Preferred Technology, LLCTerumo Kabushiki KaishaVOLCANO CORPORATIONAlex Young et al.The Boeing CompanyVMware, Inc.PIXART IMAGING INC.Facebook, Inc.General Electric Company4361423 CANADA INC.Kerr Machine Co.Samsung Electronics Co., LtdBridgestone Corporation et al.General Mills, Inc.Molecular Insight Pharmaceuticals Inc.Apple Inc.International Business Machines CorporationNetlist, Inc.3M INNOVATIVE PROPERTIES COMPANYSharp Kabushiki KaishaKaoru HatanoTRUMPF MEDIZIN SYSTEME GMBH + CO. KGMars, IncorporatedFlectere LLCRolls-Royce Corporation et al.Fangsong WANG et al.HEWLETT-PACKARD DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, L.P.CINCH GAMING EQUIPMENT LLCHanchett Entry Systems, Inc.Demaray LLCSymrise AGAVEDRO, INC.ENTIT Software LLCNicira, Inc.Amazon Technologies, Inc.Carrier CorporationThe Procter & Gamble CompanyThe Solaria CorporationGregory DanielsJames Barry et al.VOLKSWAGEN AGMedtronic, Inc.Facebook, Inc.Magic Leap, Inc.The Noco CompanyKraft Foods Group Brands LLCJohn Simms et al.Full Spectrum Inc.The NOCO CompanyMerck Sharp & Dohme Corp.James Ankrum et al.Affectiva, Inc.United Technologies CorporationAPPLIED MATERIALS, INC.ALM HOLDING CO. et al.Antony van de Ven et al.Takayasu, Masaaki et al.CC MEDIA NETWORK LIMITEDNISSAN MOTOR CO., LTD.DePuy Synthes Products, Inc.VMWARE, INC.HEWLETT PACKARD ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT LPKraft Foods R&D, Inc.FOGTEC Brandschutz GmbH & Co. KGGlobal IP Holdings, LLCPeter Kotanko et al.Xerox CorporationTreefrog Developments, Inc.Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLCPhilip Morris Products S.A.Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (publ)ERIC RESHFORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCChevron Phillips Chemical Company LPErowa AGQUALCOMM IncorporatedAT&T Intellectual Property I, L.P.LONZA LTDKimberly-Clark Global Sales, LLCMicron Technology, Inc.Jan Van Egmond et al.Juniper Networks, Inc.Facebook, Inc.Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.Tekni-Plex, Inc.Regal Beloit America, Inc.Kenneth Evans et al.Omnitek Partners LLCHalliburton Energy Services, Inc.APPLE INC.Uniloc 2017 LLC3M INNOVATIVE PROPERTIES COMPANYROCKWELL AUTOMATION TECHNOLOGIES, INC.Gregory Bleck et al.APPLE INC.Philip VaseyCytec Industries Inc.Performance Loyalty Group Inc.QUALCOMM IncorporatedSucxess LLCMicrosoft Technology Licensing, LLCCitizen Watch Co., Ltd. et al.Givaudan SAGeoffrey KwongJOSE DE LA LAMA GOMEZChristopher DraegerVERTEX PHARMACEUTICALS INCORPORATEDRobert Bosch GmbHUniversal Electronics, Inc.TIME WARNER CABLE ENTERPRISES LLCFannie MaeHuawei Technologies Co., Ltd.Brian Schablin et al.L'OREALLukka, Inc.Regal Beloit America, Inc.International Business Machines CorporationYAZAKI CORPORATIONUNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONWILLIAM PARKSTexas Instruments IncorporatedIDEAL Industries Lighting LLCIntel CorporationRaytheon CompanyL'OREALGhosh, Rishab Aiyer. et al.Apple Inc.GENERAL MILLS, INC.adidas AGUniversal Electronics, Inc.Aktiebolaget SKFMicrosoft Technology Licensing, LLC.Universal Electronics, Inc.Seagate Technology LLCINTUITIVE SURGICAL OPERATIONS, INC.Pure Storage, Inc.INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONVivante CorporationRobert Bosch GmbHMeural Inc.Alexandra Chaumonnot et al.The Procter & Gamble CompanySANDOZ AGDavid SagerIGTAvago Technologies International Sales Pte. LimitedReliance Jio Infocomm USA, Inc.KCI Licensing, Inc.QUALCOMM IncorporatedGeneral Electric CompanyConversant Wireless Licensing S.à r.l.NESTEC S.A.GOPLUG BAGS, INC.Illinois Tool Works Inc.Thaddeus GabaraBiological Innovation and Optimization Systems, LLCCalimmune, Inc. et al.Richard Dellinger et al.GENERAL MILLS, INC.MW Encap LimitedNSS Labs, Inc.Nokia Technologies OyAdvanced Micro Devices, Inc.GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANYThe Goodyear Tire & Rubber CompanyLance GOOBERMANQUALTRICS, LLCCondalign ASGoogle LLCCochlear LimitedInternational Business Machines CorporationMedtronic, Inc.STANLEY LAPIDUS et al.COMMCOPE TECHNOLOGIES LLCGoogle LLCAvalanche Technology, Inc.Corning IncorporatedGentex Corporationadidas AGAlexandre Capt et al.DOYLE, PETER L.Nokia Technologies OyBASELL POLYOLEFINE GMBHDSM IP ASSETS B.V.QUALCOMM IncorporatedInternational Business Machines CorporationTEXAS INSTRUMENTS INCORPORATEDNTN CORPORATIONSICK AGUNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONUniversal Display CorporationRealtek Semiconductor Corp.Sciperio, IncSMITHS MEDICAL ASD, INC.SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD.Theranos, Inc.Luca DONETTI et al.CGG SERVICES SAJeffrey KillianContinental Teves AG & Co. oHGSYNGENTA PARTICIPATIONS AGHenkel AG & Co. KGaASEMICONDUCTOR COMPONENTS INDUSTRIES, LLCColey Creative LLCHP PRINTING KOREA CO., LTD.BASF SENOMAD BIOSCIENCE GMBHMomentive Performance Materials Inc.Black Hills IP Holdings, LLCSEMICONDUCTOR COMPONENTS INDUSTRIES, LLCSEMICONDUCTOR COMPONENTS INDUSTRIES, LLCAndrew Kegel et al.The General Hospital CorporationSnik LLCTony Martinez et al.Min-Nan LiaoShawn Pollock et al.Steven KingAlfatex NVSCHLUMBERGER TECHNOLOGY CORPORATIONTEXAS INSTRUMENTS INCORPORATEDTelefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (publ)S.P.C.M. SASHIN-ETSU CHEMICAL CO., LTD. et al.DELL PRODUCTS L.P.ICEOTOPE LIMITEDMikel Stanich et al.Regents of the University of MinnesotaBOSTON SCIENTIFIC SCIMEDDigitech Systems Private Reserve, LLCShahram Dastmalchi et al.Nokia Technologies Oy3M INNOVATIVE PROPERTIES COMPANYMERCK PATENT GMBHEdwards Lifesciences CorporationRobyn Haines et al.MERCK PATENT GMBHInternational Business Machines CorporationHaitao Li et al.HEWLETT-PACKARD DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, L.P.Erika Hoffmann et al.Intel CorporationUnited Technologies CorporationTHE REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGANSiemens Healthcare Diagnostics Inc.Goodrich CorporationBard Access Systems, Inc.Othman AhmadSony Computer Entertainment Inc.BOREALIS AGThe Procter & Gamble CompanyAlcatel LucentXLUMENA, INC.FORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCPANASONIC INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT CO., LTD.Peter Ward et al.BOSTON SCIENTIFIC SCIMED, INC.OTIS ELEVATOR COMPANYACIST Medical Systems, Inc.Conopco, Inc., d/b/a UNILEVERNewport Fab, LLC dba Jazz Semiconductor, Inc.International Business Machines CorporationHovid BerhadROCHE MOLECULAR SYSTEMS, INC.Zeus Industrial Products, Inc.HALLIBURTON ENERGY SERVICES, INC.R.J. Reynolds Tobacco CompanyTexas Instruments IncorporatedUNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONTop SecretFLIPN'SWEET, LLCMasterCard International IncorporatedHB BIOTECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONUNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONReplyBuy, Inc.Nordson Corporation4361423 CANADA INC.Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc.FISHER-ROSEMOUNT SYSTEMS, INC.AP&C ADVANCED POWDERS & COATINGS INC.Tigo Energy, Inc.OY LANGH TECH ABComcast Cable Communications Management, LLCSUNCOKE TECHNOLOGY AND DEVELOPMENT LLCMichelle FisherWHIRLPOOL CORPORATIONQUALCOMM IncorporatedMasterCard International IncorporatedDaniel Weldon et al.Nantomics, LLCLifeQ Global LimitedTom BrownComcast Cable Communications, LLCInnovative Foundry Technologies LLCStephen GassFlectere LLCUniloc 2017 LLCTARGET BRANDS INC.Drägerwerk AG & Co. KGaAKent TaborKlKUSUI SEISAKUSHO LTD.Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLCMarcel MatiereUNITED STATES GYPSUM COMPANYApple Inc.Lawrence Livermore National Security, LLC et al.Gaston GLOCKGala Industries, Inc.Jae Kun Lee et al.Toshiba Memory CorporationApple Inc.Eldad Klaiman et al.Sony CorporationMYSCRIPTSchlage Lock Company LLCZAGG Intellectual Property Holding Co., Inc.WEINMANN GERAETE FUER MEDIZIN GMBH + CO. KGTHE BOEING COMPANYFord Global Technologies, LLCNetlist, Inc.ROHDE & SCHWARZ GMBH & CO. KGNIPPON STEEL COATED SHEET CORPORATIONVisa International Service AssociationSucxess LLCSEB S.A.Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp.ILLINOIS TOOL WORKS INC.Siemens Healthcare Diagnostics Inc.W. R. GRACE & CO.-CONN.TeleTracking Technologies, Inc.Jacqueline Reid et al.PHILIPS LIGHTING HOLDING B.V.ROBERT BOSCH GMBHMark Olsson et al.International Business Machines CorporationVMware, Inc.Zinus Inc.PILKINGTON GROUP LIMITEDGENERAL ELECTRIC TECHNOLOGY GMBHGeneral Electric CompanyHARTING Electric GmbH & Co. KGWang, Kaihong Hunter HD, LLCRichpower Industries, Inc.Gulfstream Aerospace CorporationTaiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company, Ltd.Navico Holding ASPHILIPS LIGHTING HOLDING B.V.Adobe Inc.Justin Samuels et al.9754741Canada LtdIntel CorporationExxonMobil Chemical Patents Inc.NISSAN MOTOR CO., LTD.PHILIPS LIGHTING HOLDING B.V.National Products Inc.SawStop Holding LLC3M INNOVATIVE PROPERTIES COMPANYVOLKSWAGEN AKTIENGESELLSCHAFTPHILIPS LIGHTING HOLDING B.V.Home Depot Product Authority, LLCNESTEC S.A.Stephen Ellis et al.International Business Machines CorporationOatly ABIRDETO B.V.LENOVO (Singapore) PTE. LTD.Bruce KnutesonDONALD DANFORTH PLANT SCIENCE CENTERMcAfee, Inc.SHISEIDO COMPANY, LTD.International Business Machines CorporationPure Storage, Inc.Satoru OSAKO et al.S. C. Johnson & Son, Inc.AR Design Innovations LLCMURATA MANUFACTURING CO., LTD.Robert Davis et al.NXP B.V.Micron Technology, Inc.3M INNOVATIVE PROPERTIES COMPANYVMware, Inc.Google LLCInnovative Foundry Technologies LLCAXENIC POWER, LLCFraunhofer-Gesellschaft zur Förderung der angewandten Forschung c.V.Lars Winther et al.ECOLAB USA INC.Adobe Inc.Medtronic, Inc.ENTIT Software LLCApple Inc.JOLED INC.Alcatel LucentKOMPETENZZENTRUM - DAS VIRTUELLE FAHRZEUG FORSCHUNGSGESELLSCHAFT MBHCommScope Connectivity UK LimitedSEMICONDUCTOR COMPONENTS INDUSTRIES, LLCTatsuo Tomomori et al.Roland Proksa et al.Panasonic Intellectual Property Management Co., Ltd.Adobe Inc.HALLIBURTON ENERGY SERVICES, INC. et al.APPLE INC.Carl Zeiss Microscopy GmbHHARMAN INTERNATIONAL INDUSTRIES, INCCOVIDIEN LPFord Global Technologies, LLCEric ReshApple Inc.Societe des Produits Nestle SAThe Toronto-Dominion BankHammond Development International, Inc.JFE STEEL CORPORATIONUnited Technologies CorporationIkorongo Technology LLCAlice O'Donnell KielyLargan Precision Co., Ltd.ImmerVision, Inc.EMC CorporationMasterCard International IncorporatedHUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.Veeva Systems Inc.Robert HydroMicrosoft Technology Licensing, LLCUniloc 2017 LLCFAIR ISAAC CORPORATIONSnik LLCMurata Manufacturing Co., Ltd.Nokia Solutions and Networks OyKBA-NOTASYS SA et al.Omoidesouzou Co., Ltd. et al.INNOSPEC LIMITEDAdvanced Micro Devices, Inc.Laura Brown et al.UNISON HOLDINGS LLCR 421A LLCOracle America, Inc.MACHINES CORPORATION, INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS Applied Materials, Inc.Richard JonesRehrig Pacific CompanyVMWARE, INC.Facebook, Inc.THE PROCTER & GAMBLE COMPANYThe Procter & Gamble CompanyEndress + Hauser Conducta Gesellschaft für Mess- und Regeltechnik mbH + Co. KGFord Global Technologies, LLC3M INNOVATIVE PROPERTIES COMPANYDensys LTD.AUDI AGTHE SPECTRANETICS CORPORATIONKOMATSU LTD.Ashish PALEKAR et al.PATHEON SOFTGELS INCYAZAKI CORPORATIONNippon Sheet Glass Company, LimitedMatthew PetersonHewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P.Johnson & Johnson Consumer Inc.Colibri Heart Valve LLCHammond Development International, Inc.John Baumann et al.BASF CorporationCGG SERVICES SASMarkus Bartholet et al.Apple Inc.Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd.Medtronic, Inc.KHS GmbHSunil Kumar et al.Nvidia Corporation3M INNOVATIVE PROPERTIES COMPANYApple Inc.JEOL Ltd.Robert Bosch GmbHJames CollieCatherine McClellanNicira, Inc.HOLOGIC, INC.Anthony Kihm et al.Auction.com, LLCIntel CorporationNESTEC S.A.Trunomi Ltd.Treefrog Developments, Inc.Bendix Commercial Vehicle Systems LLC4LIFE PATENTS, LLCHOLOGIC, INC.Becton, Dickinson and CompanyTELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON (PUBL)XMTT, Inc.PRATT & WHITNEY CANADA CORP.INSERM (INSTITUT NATIONAL DE LA SANTÉ ET DE LA RECHERCHE MÉDICALE et al.Amadeus S.A.S.GRUPO PETROTEMEX, S.A. DE C.V.GIVAUDAN SAImagination Technologies LimitedSarah ChinThaddeus GabaraUNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONKerr Machine Co.DISH Technologies L.L.C.Ikorongo Technology LLCPatagonia, Inc.CGG SERVICES SAMaxx Media Group, LLC3M INNOVATIVE PROPERTIES COMPANYInternational Business Machines CorporationHUSQVARNA ABCarel Theo Jozef Wreesmann et al.SHARP KABUSHIKI KAISHASEB S.A.Quertle LLCBayerische Motoren Werke AktiengesellschaftGary BorodicEndress + Hauser Conducta Gesellschaft für Mess- und Regeltechnik mbH + Co. KGThe Boeing CompanyRoche Diagnostics Operations, Inc.IVANTIS, INCElematic OyjInternational Business Machines CorporationGoodrich CorporationVIRNETX INC. (OWNER) et al.Lori SkerjanzGary BorodicJuniper Networks, Inc.ECHOSTAR TECHNOLOGIES L.L.C.Karen West et al.INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONStryker European Holdings I, LLCMitsubishi Electric CorporationThe Boeing CompanySCHNEIDER ELECTRIC USA, INC.Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (publ)TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON (PUBL)Jay Otto et al.Coinplug, Inc.Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLCWeatherford Technology Holdings, LLCJian HanThe Quaker Oats CompanySOLUTIA INC. Alice Mary. KielySEMICONDUCTOR COMPONENTS INDUSTRIES, LLCASML Netherlands B.V.Jesus Barcons-Palau et al.David SACKS et al.Netlist, Inc.ILLINOIS TOOL WORKS INC.AR Design Innovations LLCSEMICONDUCTOR ENERGY LABORATORY CO., LTD.Breezometer Ltd.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.Global Analytics, Inc.Dropbox, Inc.SIMON Technologies LLCVCE Company, LLCFirst Solar, Inc.Herbert TownsendLargan Precision Co., Ltd.Mark O'Masta et al.VISA U.S.A. INC.Vios Medical, Inc.QUALCOMM IncorporatedFitbit, Inc.Cellwitch Inc.Ficep CorporationInternational Business Machines CorporationUNIVERSAL CITY STUDIOS LLCPerkinElmer Health Sciences, Inc.Apple Inc.Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc.Board of Regents of the University of NebraskaHilti AktiengesellschaftRATIONAL AKTIENGESELLSCHAFTDONALD MURTHACOMENITY LLCNivarox-FAR S.A.The Boeing CompanyKONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.Universal Electronics, Inc.Yulun Wang et al.