Section 75-02-06-16.3 - Rate determinations for price1. Rate determination. a. For the direct cost category, the actual rate is calculated using allowable historical operating costs and adjustment factors provided for in subsection 4 divided by standardized resident days. The actual rate must include the margin cap. The actual rate as calculated is compared to the price rate to determine the lesser of the actual rate or the price rate. The lesser rate is given the rate weight of one. The rate weight of one for direct care is then multiplied times the weight for each classification in subsection 5 of section 75-02-06-17 to establish the direct care rate for that classification.b. For the other direct cost category, the actual rate is calculated using allowable historical operating costs and adjustment factors provided for in subsection 5 divided by resident days. The actual rate must include the margin cap. The actual rate as calculated is compared to the price rate to determine the lesser of the actual rate or the price rate.c. For the indirect cost category, the actual rate is calculated using allowable historical operating costs and adjustment factors provided for in subsection 5 divided by resident days subject to the adjustments provided for in subdivision i of subsection 3. The actual rate must include the margin cap. The actual rate as calculated is compared to the price rate to determine the lesser of the actual rate or the price rate.d. For the passthrough costs category, the actual rate is calculated using allowable historical operating costs divided by resident days subject to the adjustments provided for in subdivision i of subsection 3.e. The property rate must be the greater of the fair rental value rate or the rate calculated using allowable property costs subject to subsection 2. The property rate must be calculated using resident days subject to the adjustments provided for in subdivision i of subsection 3. f. The lesser of the actual rate or the price rate for other direct care and indirect care, the passthrough rate, the property rate, and the adjustments provided for in subsection 3 are then added to the direct care rate for each classification to arrive at the established rate for a given classification.2. Effective with the 2023 rate year and subsequent rate years:a. If the fair rental value rate is greater than the rate calculated using allowable property costs: (1) The increase must be phased in over a four-year period.(2) The increase must be reserved for renovations or replacements that enhance the fair rental value.(3) The increase must be reserved until a renovation or replacement of at least two thousand dollars per licensed bed is placed in service. Only allowable costs for building, land improvements, and fixed equipment may be used in calculating the amount per licensed bed.b. If the fair rental value rate is less than the rate calculated using allowable property costs:(1) The department shall inform the facility of the property rate using allowable property costs and the fair rental value rate.(2) Annually by November twenty-eighth, the facility shall inform the department if they want to accept the rate calculated using allowable property costs as the property rate.c. Once the fair rental value rate is equal to or greater than the rate calculated using allowable property costs, or the facility does not inform the department they want to accept the rate calculated using allowable property costs, the department no longer may inform the facility of the rate calculated using allowable property costs and the property rate must be the fair rental value rate.3. Limitations. a. The department shall accumulate and analyze statistics on costs incurred by facilities. Statistics may be used to establish reasonable ceiling limitations and incentives for efficiency and economy based on reasonable determination of standards of operations necessary for efficient delivery of needed services. Limitations and incentives may be established on the basis of cost of comparable facilities and services and may be applied as ceilings on the overall costs of providing services or on specific areas of operations. The department may implement ceilings at any time based upon information available.b. The department shall review, on an ongoing basis, aggregate payments to facilities to determine that payments do not exceed an amount that can reasonably be estimated would have been paid for those services under Medicare payment principles. If aggregate payments to facilities exceed estimated payments under Medicare, the department may make adjustments to rates to establish the upper limitations so that aggregate payments do not exceed an amount that can be estimated would have been paid under Medicare payment principles.c. All facilities, except those nongeriatric facilities for individuals with physical disabilities or units within a nursing facility providing geropsychiatric services described in North Dakota Century Code section 50-24.4-13, must be used to establish a price rate for the direct care and other direct care cost categories. The base year is the report year ended June 30, 2021. A new base year will be established using the report year ended June 30, 2023. Base year costs may not be adjusted in any manner or for any reason not provided for in this subsection or subsection 4.d. All facilities must be grouped into peer groups based on the licensed bed capacity available for occupancy as of June thirtieth of the report year. Facilities in each peer group must be used to establish a price rate for the indirect care cost category for that peer group. The base year is the report year ended June 30, 2021. A new base year will be established using the report year ended June 30, 2023. Base year costs may not be adjusted in any manner or for any reason not provided for in this subsection or subsection 4.e. The price rate for each of the cost categories must be established using historical operating costs for the base year. The price rate will be established using the same percentage of the median used to establish the limit rates for the January 1, 2021, rate year.f. A facility with an actual rate that exceeds the price rate for a cost category shall receive the price rate.g. The price rate for each of the cost categories for the January 1, 2023, rate year must be the price rate for the previous rate year increased by the adjustment factor.h. The price rate for each of the cost categories for the January 1, 2025, rate year must be the price rate for the previous rate year increased by the adjustment factor.i. The actual rate for indirect care costs, passthrough costs, and the fair rental value rate must be the lesser of the rate established using:(1) Actual census for the report year; or(2) Ninety percent of licensed bed capacity available for occupancy as of June thirtieth of the report year:(a) Multiplied times three hundred sixty-five; and(b) Reduced by the number of affected beds, for each day any bed is not in service during the report year, due to a remodeling, renovation, or construction project.j. The department may waive or reduce the application of subdivision i if the facility demonstrates that occupancy below ninety percent of licensed capacity results from the use of alternative home and community services by individuals who would otherwise be eligible for admission to the facility and: (1) The facility has reduced licensed capacity; or(2) The facility's governing board has approved a capacity decrease to occur no later than the end of the rate year that would be affected by subdivision i.k. The department may waive the application of subdivision i for nongeriatric facilities for individuals with disabilities or geropsychiatric facilities or units if occupancy below ninety percent is due to lack of department-approved referrals or admissions.l. When calculating the fair rental value rate:(1) The maximum allowable square footage must be nine hundred fifty square feet [88.26 square meters] per licensed bed.(2) The replacement value of land will be ten percent of the building replacement cost.(3) The maximum allowable moveable equipment replacement value must be fifteen thousand dollars per licensed bed.(4) The maximum annual replacement cost inflation factor for building and land must be two percent.(5) The maximum annual depreciation factor for building must be two percent.(6) The location factor must be the city of Minneapolis.(7) The minimum allowable project to impact a facility's effective age must be one thousand dollars per licensed bed. Only allowable costs for building, land improvements, and fixed equipment may be used in calculating the amount per licensed bed.(8) The maximum allowable rental rate must be eight percent.(9) The building replacement cost must be calculated by multiplying a facility's allowable square footage times the cost per square foot adjusted for the location factor. The building replacement cost per square foot must be for a thirty thousand square foot [2787.09 square meter] building with exterior walls of precast concrete for the calendar year before the end of the cost report year.(10) A facility's effective age may be updated due to a renovation project reported in the cost report year the project was completed. The following will be used when calculating the update: (a) The cost per square foot adjusted for the location factor for the cost report year in which the renovation project was completed.(b) Additional square footage added due to the renovation project must be included in the total square footage.(c) Only allowable renovation project costs for building, land improvements, and fixed equipment.4. An adjustment factor must be used for purposes of adjusting historical operating costs for direct care, other direct care, and indirect care under subsection 1 and for purposes of adjusting the price rate for direct care costs, other direct care costs, and indirect care costs under subsection 3, but may not be used to adjust passthrough costs and the fair rental value under either subsection 1 or 3.5. Rate adjustments. a. Desk audit rate. (1) The cost report must be reviewed taking into consideration the prior year's adjustments. The facility must be notified by electronic mail of any adjustments based on the desk review. Within seven working days after notification, the facility may submit information to explain why the desk adjustment should not be made. The department shall review the information and make appropriate adjustments.(2) The desk audit rate must be effective January first of each rate year unless the department specifically identifies an alternative effective date and must continue in effect until a final rate is established.(3) Until a final rate is effective, pursuant to paragraph 3 of subdivision b, private-pay rates may not exceed the desk audit rate, except as provided for in section 75-02-06-22 or subdivision c.(4) The facility may request a reconsideration of the desk rate for purposes of establishing a pending decision rate. The request for reconsideration must be filed with the department's medical services division within thirty days of the date of the rate notification and must contain the information required in subsection 1 of section 75-02-06-26. A decision on the request for reconsideration of the desk rate may not be made by the department unless, after the facility has been notified that the desk rate is the final rate, the facility requests, in writing within thirty days of the rate notification, the department to issue a decision on that request for reconsideration.(5) The desk rate may be adjusted for special rates or one-time adjustments provided for in this section.(6) The desk rate may be adjusted to reflect errors, adjustments, or omissions for the report year which result in a change of at least the rate adjustment percentage per day.b. Final rate. (1) The cost report may be field audited to establish a final rate. If a field audit is not performed, the desk audit rate must become the final rate upon notification from the department. The final rate is effective January first of each rate year, unless the department specifically identifies an alternative effective date.(2) The final rate must include any adjustments for nonallowable costs, errors, or omissions that result in a change from the desk audit rate of at least the rate adjustment percentage per day which are found during a field audit or are reported by the facility within twelve months of the rate year end.(3) The private-pay rate must be adjusted to the final rate no later than the first day of the second month following receipt of notification by the department of the final rate and is not retroactive, except as provided for in subdivision c.(4) The final rate may be revised at any time for special rates or one-time adjustments provided for in this section.(5) If adjustments, errors, or omissions are found after a final rate has been established, the following procedures must be used:(a) Adjustments, errors, or omissions found within twelve months of establishment of the final rate, not including subsequent revisions, resulting in a change of at least the rate adjustment percentage per day must result in a change to the final rate. The change must be applied retroactively as provided for in this section.(b) Adjustments, errors, or omissions found later than twelve months after the establishment of the final rate, not including subsequent revisions, which would have resulted in a change of at least the rate adjustment percentage per day had they been included, must be included as an adjustment in the report year that the adjustment, error, or omission was found.(c) The two report years immediately preceding the report year to which the adjustments, errors, or omissions apply may also be reviewed for similar adjustments, errors, or omissions.c. Pending decision rates for private-pay residents.(1) If a facility has made a request for reconsideration, taken an administrative appeal, or taken a judicial appeal from a decision on an administrative appeal, and has provided information sufficient to allow the department to accurately calculate, on a per-day basis, the effect of each of the disputed issues on the facility's rate, the department shall determine and issue a pending decision rate within thirty days of receipt of the request for reconsideration, administrative appeal, or judicial appeal. If the information furnished is insufficient to determine a pending decision rate, the department, within thirty days of receipt of the request for reconsideration, shall inform the facility of the insufficiency and may identify information that would correct the insufficiency.(2) The department shall add the pending decision rate to the rate that would otherwise be set under this chapter, and, notwithstanding North Dakota Century Code section 50-24.4-19, the total must be the rate chargeable to private-pay residents until a final decision on the request for reconsideration or appeal is made and is no longer subject to further appeal. The pending decision rate is subject to any rate limitation that may apply.(3) The facility shall establish and maintain records that reflect the amount of any pending decision rate paid by each private-pay resident from the date the facility charges a private-pay resident the pending decision rate.(4) If the pending decision rate paid by a private-pay resident exceeds the final decision rate, the facility shall refund the difference, plus interest accrued at the legal rate from the date of notification of the pending decision rate, within sixty days after the final decision is no longer subject to appeal. If a facility fails to provide a timely refund to a living resident or former resident, the facility shall pay interest at three times the legal rate for the period after the refund is due. If a former resident is deceased, the facility shall pay the refund to a person lawfully administering the estate of the deceased former resident or lawfully acting as successor to the deceased former resident. If no person is lawfully administering the estate or lawfully acting as a successor, the facility may make any disposition of the refund permitted by law. Interest paid under this subsection is not an allowable cost.d. The final rate as established must be retroactive to the effective date of the desk rate, except with respect to rates paid by private-pay residents. A pending decision rate is not subject to adjustment or refund until a decision on the disputed amount is made.6. Rate payments. a. The rate as established must be considered as payment for all accommodations and includes all items designated as routinely provided. Payments may not be solicited or received from the resident or any other person to supplement the rate as established.b. The rate as established must be paid by the department only if the rate charged to private-pay residents for semiprivate accommodations equals the established rate. If at any time the facility discounts rates for private-pay residents, the discounted rate must be the maximum chargeable to the department for the same bed type, i.e., hospital or leave days. c. If the established rate exceeds the rate charged to a private-pay resident, on any given date, the facility immediately shall report that fact to the department and charge the department at the lower rate. If payments were received at the higher rate, the facility, within thirty days, shall refund the overpayment. The refund must be the difference between the established rate and the rate charged the private-pay resident times the number of medical assistance resident days paid during the period in which the established rate exceeded the rate charged to private-pay residents, plus interest calculated at two percent over the Bank of North Dakota prime rate on any amount not repaid within thirty days. The refund provision also applies to all duplicate billings involving the department. Interest charges on these refunds are not allowable costs.d. Peer groupings, limitations, or adjustments based upon data received from or relating to more than one facility are effective for a rate period. Any change in the data used to establish peer groupings, limitations, or adjustments may not be used to change such peer groupings, limitations, or adjustments during the rate period, except with respect to the specific facility or facilities to which the data change relates.e. The established rate is paid based on a prospective ratesetting procedure. No retroactive settlements for actual costs incurred during the rate year which exceed the established rate may be made unless specifically provided for in this section.7. Partial year.a. Rates for a facility changing ownership during the rate period are set under this subdivision. (1) The rates established for direct care, other direct care, indirect care, and passthrough for the previous owner must be retained through the end of the rate period and the rates for the next rate period following the change in ownership must be established: (a) For a facility with six or more months of operation under the new ownership during the report year, through use of a cost report for the period;(b) For a facility with less than six months of operation under the new ownership during the report year, by indexing the rates established for the previous owner forward using the adjustment factor in subsection 5; or(c) If the change of ownership occurred after the report year end, but before the beginning of the next rate year, and the previous owner submits and allows audit of a cost report, by establishing a rate based on the previous owner's cost report.(2) The fair rental value rate established for the previous owner must be retained.b. For a new facility placed into service before December 31, 2022, the department shall establish a rate equal to the price rate for direct care, other direct care, and indirect care in effect for the rate year in which the facility begins operation, plus the projected property rate. The projected property rate is subject to subdivision f. For the rate period following submission of any partial year cost report by a facility, census used to establish rates for property and indirect care costs must be the greater of actual census, projected census, or census imputed at ninety-five percent of licensed beds.(1) If the effective date of the rate is on or after January first and on or before June thirtieth, the rate must be effective for the remainder of that rate year and must continue through June thirtieth of the subsequent rate year. The facility shall file by March first a cost report for the period ending December thirty-first of the year in which the facility first provides services. The cost report is used to establish the actual rate effective July first of the subsequent rate year. The partial year rate established based on this cost report must include applicable margins and adjustment factors and may not be subject to any cost settle-up.(2) If the effective date of the rate is on or after July first and on or before December thirty-first, the rate must remain in effect through the end of the subsequent rate year. The facility shall file a cost report for the partial report year ending June thirtieth of the subsequent rate year. This cost report must be used to establish the rate for the next subsequent rate year.c. For a new facility placed into service after December 31, 2022, the department shall establish a rate equal to the price rate for direct care, other direct care, and indirect care in effect for the rate year in which the facility begins operation, plus the fair rental value rate.d. For a facility with a major renovation of at least fifteen thousand dollars per licensed bed: (1) If the renovation is placed into service between July first and December thirty-first, a fair rental value rate must be calculated including the major renovation. The fair rental value rate must be effective July first of the subsequent rate year.(2) If the renovation is placed into service between January first and June thirtieth, a fair rental value rate must be calculated including the major renovation. The fair rental value rate must be effective January first of the subsequent rate year.e. For a facility terminating its participation in the medical assistance program, whether voluntarily or involuntarily, the department may authorize the facility to receive continued payment until medical assistance residents can be relocated to facilities participating in the medical assistance program.f. For a projected property rate in place before January 1, 2023, at such time as twelve months of property costs are reflected in the report year, the difference between a projected property rate and the property rate that would otherwise be established based on historical costs must be determined. The property rate paid in each of the twelve years, beginning with the first rate year following the use of a projected property rate reduced by one-twelfth of that difference.8. One-time adjustments. a. Adjustments to meet certification standards.(1) The department may provide for an increase in the established rate for additional costs incurred to meet certification standards. The survey conducted by the department's public health division must clearly require that the facility take steps to correct deficiencies dealing with resident care. The plan of correction must identify the salary and other costs that must be increased to correct the deficiencies cited in the survey process.(2) The facility shall submit a written request to the medical services division within thirty days of submitting the plan of correction to the department's public health division. The request must:(a) Include a statement that costs or staff numbers have not been reduced for the report year immediately preceding the department's public health division's certification survey;(b) Identify the number of new staff or additional staff hours and the associated costs required to meet the certification standards; and(c) Provide a detailed list of any other costs necessary to meet survey standards.(3) The department shall review the submitted information and may request additional documentation or conduct onsite visits. If an increase in costs is approved, the established rate must be adjusted to an amount not to exceed the price rate.(4) Any additional funds provided must be used in accordance with the facility's written request to the department and are subject to audit. If the department determines the funds were not used for the intended purpose, an adjustment must be made in accordance with subsection 5.b. Adjustments for unforeseeable expenses.(1) The department may provide for an increase in the established rate for additional costs incurred to meet major unforeseeable expenses. The expenses must be resident related and must be beyond the control of those responsible for the management of the facility.(2) Within sixty days after first incurring the unforeseeable expense, the facility shall submit a written request to the medical services division containing the following information:(a) An explanation as to why the facility believes the expense was unforeseeable;(b) An explanation as to why the facility believes the expense was beyond the managerial control of the facility; and(c) A detailed breakdown of the unforeseeable expenses by expense line item.(3) The department shall base its decision on whether the request clearly demonstrates that the economic or other factors that caused the expense were unexpected and arose because of conditions that could not have been anticipated by management based on its background and knowledge of nursing care industry and business trends.(4) The department shall review the submitted information and may request additional documentation or conduct onsite visits. If an increase in costs is approved, the established rate must be adjusted upward, not to exceed the price rate.(5) Any additional funds provided must be used to meet the unforeseeable expenses outlined in the facility's request to the department and are subject to audit. If the department determines that the funds were not used for the intended purpose, an adjustment must be made in accordance with subsection 5.c. Adjustment to historical operating costs. (1) A facility may receive a one-time adjustment to historical operating costs when the facility has been found to be significantly below care-related minimum standards described in subparagraph a of paragraph 2 and when it has been determined the facility cannot meet the minimum standards through reallocation of costs and use of margin cap. (2) The following conditions must be met before a facility can receive the adjustment: (a) The facility shall document, based on nursing hours and standardized resident days, the facility cannot provide a minimum of one and two-tenths nursing hours per standardized resident day;(b) The facility shall document all available resources, including margin cap, if used to increase nursing hours, are not sufficient to meet the minimum standards; and(c) The facility shall submit a written plan describing how the facility will meet the minimum standard if the adjustment is received, including the number and type of staff to be added to the current staff and the projected cost for salary and fringe benefits for the additional staff.(3) The adjustment must be calculated based on the costs necessary to increase nursing hours to the minimum standards less any margin cap included when calculating the established rate. The net increase must be divided by standardized resident days and the amount calculated must be added to the rate. This rate is subject to any price rate limitations that may apply.(4) If the facility fails to implement the plan to increase nursing hours to one and two-tenths hours per standardized resident day, the amount included as the adjustment must be adjusted in accordance with the methodologies set forth in subsection 5.(5) If the cost of implementing the plan exceeds the amount included as the adjustment, no retroactive settlement may be made.d. Adjustments for disaster recovery costs when evacuation of residents occurs. (1) A facility may incur certain costs when recovering from a disaster, such as a flood, tornado, or fire. If evacuation of residents was necessary because of the disaster, actual recovery costs during the evacuation period, net of insurance recoveries, may be considered as deferred charges and allocated over a number of periods that benefit from the costs.(2) When a facility has evacuated residents and capitalizes recovery costs as a deferred charge, the recovery costs must be recognized as allowable costs amortized over sixty consecutive months beginning with the sixth month after the first resident is readmitted to the facility.(3) Recovery costs must be identified as startup costs and included as passthrough costs for report purposes. Recovery costs are not subject to any limitations except as provided in paragraph 4.(4) If a facility evacuates residents, the ninety percent occupancy limitation may not be applied during the recovery period or for the first six months following the month the facility readmits the first resident.(5) Insurance recoveries relating to the disaster recovery period must be reported as a reduction of recovery costs. Insurance recoveries received after the first month of the sixty-month amortization period must be included as a reduction of deferred charges not yet amortized, except that the reduction for insurance recoveries may occur only at the beginning of a rate year. e. Adjustments for a significant reduction in census.(1) A facility may request a revised desk rate if the facility has a significant reduction in census. The reduction in census cannot be due to renovation.(2) For purposes of this section a significant reduction in census is defined as: (a) At least ten percent of licensed bed capacity for a facility in the large peer group; and(b) At least five percent of licensed bed capacity for a facility in the small peer group.(3) The licensed bed capacity will be based on the licensed beds used to establish the peer groups.(4) The revised desk rate must be calculated using:(a) The facility's allowable historical operating costs from the most recent base year increased by the adjustment factors, if any, up to the current report year.(b) The facility's allowable property costs from the most recent report year.(c) The standardized resident days and resident days from the most recent report year.(d) The revised desk rate must be limited to the price rate for direct care, other direct care, and indirect cost categories.(5) A facility that receives a revised desk rate under this section may not increase licensed bed capacity during the rate year.9. Under no circumstances, including an appeal or judicial decision to the effect a rate was erroneously established, may a rate adjustment be made to any rate established under this chapter, unless the cumulative impact of all adjustments not already included in the established rate equals or exceeds the rate adjustment percentage per day.N.D. Admin Code 75-02-06-16.3
Adopted by Administrative Rules Supplement 2021-383, January 2022, effective 1/1/2022.Amended by Administrative Rules Supplement 2022-386, October 2022, effective 10/1/2022.Amended by Administrative Rules Supplement 2023-391, January 2024, effective 1/1/2024.General Authority: NDCC 50-24.1-04, 50-24.4-02
Law Implemented: NDCC 50-24.4