From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Georgia Power Company v. Gibson

Supreme Court of Georgia
Feb 19, 1970
226 Ga. 165 (Ga. 1970)

Summary

In Georgia Power Company v. Gibson, 226 Ga. 165, 173 S.E.2d 217 (1970) Georgia Power Company alleged adverse possession of a prescriptive easement for more than twenty years or adverse possession under color of title for seven years.

Summary of this case from Higdon v. Davis

Opinion

25647.

ARGUED FEBRUARY 9, 1970.

DECIDED FEBRUARY 19, 1970.

Equitable petition. Clarke Superior Court. Before Judge Barrow.

Erwin, Epting, Gibson Chilivis, Eugene A. Epting, for appellant.

Edgar Neely, III, Stack O'Brien, E. Hearst Roane, Scott Alexander, Guy B. Scott, Jr., for appellees.


The present petition was filed against the Georgia Power Company and Jerry Marshall to set aside a deed by Marshall as grantor purporting to convey an easement to the Georgia Power Company across described lands which the plaintiffs together with Marshall had inherited from their grandfather. The defendant Georgia Power Company filed a motion for summary judgment which was overruled and upon the certification of such judgment for review the appeal was filed. The position of the Georgia Power Company is that they showed adverse possession for more than twenty years or adverse possession under color of title for more than seven years. Held:

1. The deed from the plaintiffs' co-tenant would be a binding deed on the plaintiffs to support possession under color of title. Compare Street v. Collier, 118 Ga. 470 (6) ( 45 S.E. 294); Davis v. Harnesberger, 211 Ga. 625, 627 ( 87 S.E.2d 841).

2. Prescriptive title to an easement is governed by the same rules as prescriptive title to land. Code § 85-409; Warlick v. Rome Loan c. Co., 194 Ga. 419 (1) ( 22 S.E.2d 61).

3. Where a writing to support color of title is forged or fraudulent and notice of such fact is brought home to the claimant thereunder before or at the time of the commencement of his possession no prescription shall be based thereon. Code § 85-407.

4. In opposition to the motion for summary judgment the plaintiff introduced records of the Georgia Power Company obtained through discovery which showed that Georgia Power Company knew that Jerry Green, the plaintiff's grandfather, died prior to January 5, 1914, leaving ten children and no record title was in Jerry Marshall.

(a) Nothing more appearing such evidence would have presented a jury question as to whether the possession of Georgia Power Company would support a claim of adverse possession.

5. The above documentary evidence also disclosed that Jerry Green's estate was represented in 1915. If it be assumed that such representation continued then the failure to act within seven years barred the claim by laches. If such representation be assumed not to have continued for more than seven years then, since Code §§ 3-803 and 85-413 only toll the statute of limitation for five years, more than seven years would have expired since the expiration of any combination of times possible since the grant of the easement by the tenant in common, and even assuming that the original possession by Georgia Power Company was such that it would not support adverse possession under color of title, yet the plaintiffs are barred by laches from setting such easement aside. Compare Harrison v. Holsenbeck, 208 Ga. 410 ( 67 S.E.2d 311). No facts are shown as to the plaintiffs not having notice of such adverse possession since its inception. The trial court erred in denying the motion for summary judgment filed by Georgia Power Company.

Judgment reversed. All the Justices concur.

ARGUED FEBRUARY 9, 1970 — DECIDED FEBRUARY 19, 1970.


Summaries of

Georgia Power Company v. Gibson

Supreme Court of Georgia
Feb 19, 1970
226 Ga. 165 (Ga. 1970)

In Georgia Power Company v. Gibson, 226 Ga. 165, 173 S.E.2d 217 (1970) Georgia Power Company alleged adverse possession of a prescriptive easement for more than twenty years or adverse possession under color of title for seven years.

Summary of this case from Higdon v. Davis
Case details for

Georgia Power Company v. Gibson

Case Details

Full title:GEORGIA POWER COMPANY v. GIBSON, Administratrix, et al

Court:Supreme Court of Georgia

Date published: Feb 19, 1970

Citations

226 Ga. 165 (Ga. 1970)
173 S.E.2d 217

Citing Cases

Talboy v. Dukes

"Prescriptive title to an easement is governed by the same rules as prescriptive title to land." Ga. Power…

Kelley v. Randolph

Even assuming appellants previously held title to one-half of the alleyway, ownership of that portion of the…