From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Avis Rent A Car System, Inc. v. Advertising & Policy Committee of Avis Rent A Car System

Court of Appeals of Texas, Houston, First District
May 12, 1988
751 S.W.2d 257 (Tex. App. 1988)

Summary

explaining that, to prevent forum shopping, filing of an original proceeding does not determine the court to which a subsequent appeal will be assigned

Summary of this case from In re Swarthout

Opinion

No. 01-88-00266-CV.

May 12, 1988.

Appeal from the 270th District Court, Harris County, Hugo A. Touchy, J.

J.R. Wallingford, Robert S. Harrell, Fulbright Jaworski, Houston, for appellants.

John B. Holstead, Vinson Elkins, Houston, for appellees.

Before EVANS, C.J., and SAM BASS and DUNN, JJ.

ORDER


The appellants, Avis Rent a Car System, Inc. and Avis, Inc. ("Avis"), have filed a motion to transfer this appeal to the Fourteenth Court of Appeals. The motion is granted.

This appeal is the third proceeding heard by an appellate court in this case. On January 31, 1985, the Fourteenth Court of Appeals issued an opinion affirming the trial court's granting of a temporary injunction. About three years later, on January 29, 1988, the Fourteenth Court of Appeals granted a motion for leave to file writ of mandamus in which Avis asked the Court to order the trial judge to enter a severance or to vacate or stay the trial court's injunction. The mandamus proceeding was ultimately dismissed as moot. The case is now before this Court on appeal from the trial on the merits.

The First and Fourteenth Courts of Appeals have concurrent geographical jurisdiction. Tex.Gov't Code sec. 22.201(b), ( o) (Vernon Pamp. 1988). To avoid the opportunity for "forum shopping," cases are assigned to either court by lot. In this assignment procedure, the trial clerk writes the numbers of the two courts on identical slips of paper and place the slips in a container. When a notice of appeal or appeal bond is filed, the trial clerk draws a number out of the container at random, in a public place, and assigns the case and any companion cases to the court of appeals for the corresponding number drawn. Tex.Gov't Code sec. 22.202(h). See also Tex. App. — Houston [1st Dist.] Loc.R. 1:40(a). An original proceeding may be filed in either the First or Fourteenth Court of Appeals, unless a related appeal or original proceeding has previously been filed in one of the two courts. In that instance, the proceeding must be filed in the court hearing the related matter. Tex.App. — Houston [1st Dist.] Loc.R. 1:121.

After an appeal has been assigned through the drawing process, it remains in the court to which it was assigned through all later proceedings. Thus, if an interlocutory appeal has been assigned by the lot process to one of the two courts, then any subsequent appeal in the case must be directed to that court. But unlike an appeal, the filing of an original proceeding does not determine the court in which all subsequent proceedings will be considered because that procedure would lend itself to forum shopping.

In this case, a drawing was made, and the appeal from the temporary injunction was assigned to the Fourteenth Court of Appeals. Accordingly, this subsequent appeal properly should be heard by the Fourteenth Court of Appeals.

It is therefore ordered that Avis' motion to transfer is granted, and the case ordered transferred to the Fourteenth Court of Appeals.


Summaries of

Avis Rent A Car System, Inc. v. Advertising & Policy Committee of Avis Rent A Car System

Court of Appeals of Texas, Houston, First District
May 12, 1988
751 S.W.2d 257 (Tex. App. 1988)

explaining that, to prevent forum shopping, filing of an original proceeding does not determine the court to which a subsequent appeal will be assigned

Summary of this case from In re Swarthout
Case details for

Avis Rent A Car System, Inc. v. Advertising & Policy Committee of Avis Rent A Car System

Case Details

Full title:AVIS RENT A CAR SYSTEM, INC. and Avis, Inc., Appellants, v. The…

Court:Court of Appeals of Texas, Houston, First District

Date published: May 12, 1988

Citations

751 S.W.2d 257 (Tex. App. 1988)

Citing Cases

In re Swarthout

When the trial court clerk failed to do so, and this Court became aware of the failure, we ordered a copy of…

Cole v. State

The Government Code provides for a procedure for random selection of all "civil and criminal cases directed…