From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

1st Nat Bank of Grand Prairie v. Lone Star Life

Supreme Court of Texas
Nov 12, 1975
529 S.W.2d 67 (Tex. 1975)

Summary

In Grand Prairie, the Texas Court of Civil Appeals' conclusion that Article 9 of the Texas Business Commerce Code rather than the equitable rule governed priority contests involving secured creditors and banks' right of setoff was expressly rejected by the Texas Supreme Court.

Summary of this case from Citibank (New York State), v. Interfirst Bank

Opinion

No. B — 5389.

October 15, 1975. Rehearing Denied November 12, 1975.

Appeal from the 191st District Court, Dallas County, Spencer Carver, J.

Haynes Boone, Donald C. Templin, Dallas, for petitioner.

Jenkens Gilchrist, William D. Sims, Jr., Dallas, for respondent.


The application of First National Bank of S.W.2d 525. In taking such action, we do no reversible error. Tex.Civ.App., 524 S.W.2d 525. In taking such action, we do not approve the holding that Chapter 9 of the Texas Business and Commerce Code controls the right of a bank to assert a set-off against the funds of a depositor. Section 9.104(9) of the Code excludes 'any right of set-off' from the application of Chapter 9.


Summaries of

1st Nat Bank of Grand Prairie v. Lone Star Life

Supreme Court of Texas
Nov 12, 1975
529 S.W.2d 67 (Tex. 1975)

In Grand Prairie, the Texas Court of Civil Appeals' conclusion that Article 9 of the Texas Business Commerce Code rather than the equitable rule governed priority contests involving secured creditors and banks' right of setoff was expressly rejected by the Texas Supreme Court.

Summary of this case from Citibank (New York State), v. Interfirst Bank

disapproving a lower court's holding that § 9-104 did not preclude application of the Article 9 priority provisions

Summary of this case from Nat. Acceptance Co. of America v. Va. Capital Bank
Case details for

1st Nat Bank of Grand Prairie v. Lone Star Life

Case Details

Full title:FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF GRAND PRAIRIE, Texas, Petitioner, v. LONE STAR LIFE…

Court:Supreme Court of Texas

Date published: Nov 12, 1975

Citations

529 S.W.2d 67 (Tex. 1975)

Citing Cases

Citibank (New York State), v. Interfirst Bank

Tex.Bus. Com. Code Ann. § 9.312(e) (Vernon 1968 and 1986 Supp.). Relying on section 9-104(9) of the Code,…

Valley Nat. Bk. v. Cotton Growers Hail Ins. Co.

1982) (rejecting majority view as "too narrow" and listing reasons); Bank of Crystal Springs v. First…