Opinion
2:21-cv-00896-JLR
07-03-2024
ZUNUM AERO, INC., Plaintiff v. THE BOEING COMPANY; BOEING HORIZONX VENTURES, LLC, Defendants.
Scott M. Danner, NY Bar #4853016 (admitted pro hac vice) Brian T. Goldman, NY Bar #5616891 (admitted pro hac vice) Charlotte Baigent, NY Bar #5979224 (admitted pro hac vice) HOLWELL SHUSTER & GOLDBERG LLP Steven W. Fogg CORR CRONIN LLP Counsel for Plaintiff John C. Hueston (Admitted Pro Hac Vice) Moez M. Kaba (Admitted Pro Hac Vice) Yegor Fursevich (Admitted Pro Hac Vice) Justin M. Greer (Admitted Pro Hac Vice) Cassidy O'Sullivan (Admitted Pro Hac Vice) HUESTON HENNIGAN LLP David A. Perez, WSBA No. 43959 Susan E. Foster WSBA No. 18030 Madeline D. Swan WSBA No. 56355 PERKINS COIE LLP 1201 Counsel for Defendants
Scott M. Danner, NY Bar #4853016
(admitted pro hac vice)
Brian T. Goldman, NY Bar #5616891
(admitted pro hac vice)
Charlotte Baigent, NY Bar #5979224
(admitted pro hac vice)
HOLWELL SHUSTER & GOLDBERG LLP
Steven W. Fogg
CORR CRONIN LLP
Counsel for Plaintiff
John C. Hueston
(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)
Moez M. Kaba
(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)
Yegor Fursevich
(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)
Justin M. Greer
(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)
Cassidy O'Sullivan
(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)
HUESTON HENNIGAN LLP
David A. Perez, WSBA No. 43959
Susan E. Foster WSBA No. 18030
Madeline D. Swan WSBA No. 56355
PERKINS COIE LLP 1201
Counsel for Defendants
STIPULATION AND [PROPOSED] ORDER ON SEALING
THE HONORABLE JAMES L. ROBART, UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE.
Pursuant to this Court's Minute Order dated June 25, 2024 (Dkt. 731, the “Minute Order”), Plaintiff Zunum Aero, Inc. (“Zunum”) and Defendants The Boeing Company and Boeing HorizonX Ventures, LLC (“Boeing”) (collectively, the “Parties”), hereby submit this Joint Stipulation and Proposed Order (“Stipulation”).
WHEREAS, pursuant to the Minute Order, the parties must file a joint stipulated motion and proposed order regarding sealing no later than 7/5/2024;
WHEREAS, the Parties have conferred regarding Zunum's sealing requests in Dkt. # 697;
WHEREAS, the Parties have conferred as to whether the following documents should remain under seal, be filed in redacted form, or be unsealed;
WHEREAS, in entering this Stipulation, Boeing does not concede that, and at this time takes no position whether, the materials or information Zunum seeks to seal does, in fact, contain that Zunum's confidential information. Boeing expressly reserves the right to argue that any such material or information does not contain confidential information. Furthermore, the Parties expressly agree that they will not argue that positions taken in this Stipulation have any bearing on whether materials or information, do, in fact, contain any confidential information or trade secrets.
NOW, THEREFORE, the Parties respectfully propose that the following documents should remain under seal, be filed in redacted form, or be unsealed, as specified in the righthand column below:
Docket 697: Zunum's Motion to Seal Exhibits Submitted with Zunum's Motion for Post-Trial Relief and Accompanying Declaration of Scott M. Danner
Document
Zunum Proposal
Boeing Proposal
Joint Proposal
[Dkt. 704] Declaration of Scott M. Danner
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 2] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 2
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 3] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 3
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 4] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 4
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 5] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 5
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 6] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 6
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 7] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 7
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 8] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 8
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 9] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 9
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 10] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 10
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 11] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 11
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 12] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 12
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 13] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 13
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 14] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 14
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 15] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 15
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 16] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 16
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 17] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 17
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 18] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 18
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 19] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 19
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 20] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 20
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 21] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 21
Redact
No position
N/A.
[Dkt. 704, Att. 22] Danner Declaration, Exhibit 22
Redact
No position
N/A.
[PROPOSED] ORDER
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT, pursuant to the Parties' Stipulation, and for good cause and compelling reasons shown: Dkt. 704, Dkt. 704 Att. 2, Dkt. 704 Att. 3, Dkt. 704 Att. 4, Dkt. 704 Att. 5, Dkt. 704 Att. 6, Dkt. 704 Att. 7, Dkt. 704 Att. 8, Dkt. 704 Att. 9, Dkt. 704 Att. 10, Dkt. 704 Att. 11, Dkt. 704 Att. 12, Dkt. 704 Att. 13, Dkt. 704 Att. 14, Dkt. 704 Att. 15, Dkt. 704 Att. 16, Dkt. 704 Att. 17, Dkt. 704 Att. 18, Dkt. 704 Att. 19, Dkt. 704 Att. 20, Dkt. 704 Att. 21, and Dkt. 704 Att. 22 shall remain as redacted on the public docket; the sealed versions of the aforementioned documents-Dkts. 705, 706, 707, 708, 709, 710, 711, 712, 713, 714, 715, 716, 717, 718. 719, 720, 721, 722, 723, 724, 725, and 726-shall remain under seal.
The court DENIES Zunum's motion to seal (Dkt. # 697) as moot.
IT IS SO ORDERED.