From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Yarbrough v. Wilson

Supreme Court of Mississippi, Division A
Jan 5, 1931
131 So. 828 (Miss. 1931)

Opinion

No. 29064.

January 5, 1931.

1. SCHOOLS AND SCHOOL DISTRICTS.

Indebtedness of separate school district remained in force as obligation thereof, notwithstanding abolition of district when included within special consolidated school district (Hemingway's Code 1927, section 8762).

2. SCHOOLS AND SCHOOL DISTRICTS.

Order creating special consolidated school district out of designated territory on petition of majority of school patrons held void, where indebtedness of separate school district included, was not assumed (Hemingway's Code 1927, section 8744; Laws 1928, chapter 117, sections 1, 3, 4).

3. SCHOOLS AND SCHOOL DISTRICTS.

Only method of incorporating separate school district into special consolidated school district is by petition of majority of school patrons in designated territory (Hemingway's Code 1927, section 8744; Laws 1928, chapter 117, sections 1, 3, 4, 7).

APPEAL from chancery court of Sunflower county. HON. J.L. WILLIAMS, Chancellor.

Forrest G. Cooper, of Indianola, for appellants.

It is not mandatory in the creation of a special consolidated school district under chapter 117 of the Laws of 1928 for it to assume the payment of the outstanding bonds of the former districts composing it.

Section 7 of chapter 117 of the Laws 1928.

Three kinds of areas may be formed into a special district. First, a consolidated school district itself may be designated a special consolidated school district. Second, any area meeting the requirements, regardless of its previous school character, may be organized as a special district if it meets the requirements. Third, two or more consolidated schools or parts of consolidated school districts may be organized into a special district.

Sections 3 and 4, chapter 117, Laws of 1928.

Since the new Act of 1928 provides a complete plan for disposing of the indebtedness of former districts, there is no need to read into this new law section 109 of the chapter 283, Laws 1924.

Moody Johnson, of Indianola, for appellees.

To organize a special consolidated school district by including in it the territory formerly constituting a municipal separate school district having an outstanding bonded indebtedness, a petition signed by a majority of the qualified electors of the remaining part of the district must first be presented to the county school board and the board of supervisors as provided by section 109, chapter 283, Laws of 1924.

Section 1, chapter 117, Laws of 1928; Lee v. Bassett, 121 So. 842.

A county school district or separate school district having an outstanding bonded indebtedness or other obligation shall not be included in an organization or annexed to special consolidated school district unless there shall be presented to the county school board a petition signed by a majority of the qualified electors of the remaining part of the said district pledging it to an assumption of said obligation by special consolidated school district.

Section 109, chapter 283, Laws 1924; Chapter 117, Laws 1928.

Argued orally by Forrest G. Cooper, for appellant, and by C.C. Moody, for appellee.


The appellees exhibited an original bill against the county superintendent of education of Sunflower county and the trustees of the Moorhead special consolidated school district, the prayer of which is that the order of the county school board creating the Moorhead special consolidated school district be declared void and the aforesaid defendants be enjoined from acting thereunder. The court below rendered a decree awarding the relief prayed for.

The case presented by the record is this: A petition properly signed, was presented to the school board of Sunflower county praying for the establishment of a special consolidated school district to be known as the Moorhead special consolidated school district. Within the territory included in the district is the town of Moorhead, which constituted a separate school district with an outstanding bonded indebtedness. After the filing of the petition, the Moorhead separate school district was abolished by the municipal authorities. Thereupon the special consolidated school district was established by an order of the school board in accordance with the petition therefor. The indebtedness of the Moorhead separate school district remains in full force as an obligation thereof, notwithstanding the abolition of the district by the municipal authorities. Section 121, chapter 283, Laws 1924, Hemingway's Code 1927, section 8762. No petition signed by a majority of the qualified electors of the territory proposed to be included in the Moorhead special consolidated district outside of the town of Moorhead, pledging the proposed district to the assumption of the bonded indebtedness of the Moorhead separate school district was filed with the county school board, or the board of supervisors, in accordance with the provisions of section 109, chapter 283, Laws 1924, Hemingway's Code 1927, section 8744. If that section applies here, the order of the school board creating the Moorhead special consolidated school district is void.

Special consolidated school districts were first provided for by chapter 117, Laws 1928. These districts differ from the consolidated school districts theretofore authorized in the areas thereof, the number of schools, and the number of pupils attending same. Three methods are provided by sections 3 and 4 of the statute for the creation, by county school boards, of special consolidated school districts:

(1) An existing consolidated school district, containing not less than twenty-five square miles of territory, and not fewer than two hundred fifty pupils, may be declared a special consolidated school district on petition of a majority of the school patrons of the district.

(2) Territory not less than twenty-five square miles in area, and having not fewer than two hundred fifty pupils, may be declared a separate school district on petition of a majority of the school patrons thereon.

(3) Two or more consolidated school districts, or parts thereof, may be declared a special consolidated school district, on petition of a majority of the patrons of each of the consolidated school districts, or parts thereof, provided the area of the special consolidated school district is not less than twenty-five square miles and it has not fewer than two hundred fifty pupils.

The special consolidated school district in the case at bar was created by the second of these methods.

Section 1 of the statute provides: "The county school board shall follow the same procedure in the organization of a special consolidated school district as that followed in the formation of a consolidated school district."

There is no room for the application of this provision of the statute to the first method hereinbefore set out for the creation of a special consolidated school district, and probably not to the third; but it can and does apply, with full force, to the second. Consequently, section 109, chapter 283, Laws 1924, Hemingway's Code 1927, section 8744, applies here, and, not having been complied with, the order creating the special consolidated school district is void.

Section 7, chapter 117, Laws 1928, relied on by counsel for the appellant as excluding the application here of section 109, chapter 283, Laws 1924, applies, as its language clearly indicates, only to districts created under the third method provided therefor and set forth in section 4 of the statute. Chapter 117, Laws 1928, nowhere refers to separate school districts by name, and the only way, under the statute, to incorporate a separate school district into a special consolidated school district is by the second method hereinbefore outlined for the creation of special consolidated school districts, or by incorporating it into a consolidated school district, and then proceeding under either the first or third methods hereinbefore outlined.

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Yarbrough v. Wilson

Supreme Court of Mississippi, Division A
Jan 5, 1931
131 So. 828 (Miss. 1931)
Case details for

Yarbrough v. Wilson

Case Details

Full title:YARBROUGH, COUNTY SUPERINTENDENT OF EDUCATION, et al. v. WILSON et al

Court:Supreme Court of Mississippi, Division A

Date published: Jan 5, 1931

Citations

131 So. 828 (Miss. 1931)
131 So. 828

Citing Cases

School Board v. Crabb

In the case of Yeager v. Merritt, 153 Miss. 64, 120 So. 832, the court held that the recitals in a petition…

State v. County School Board

Realizing this, they endeavored to evade the applicable section, and to arrogantly defy the rights of the…