From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Vine v. Vine

Supreme Court of Rhode Island. PROVIDENCE
Feb 10, 1899
21 R.I. 190 (R.I. 1899)

Opinion

February 10, 1899.

PRESENT: Matteson, C.J., Stiness and Tillinghast, JJ.

(1) Divorce. Jurisdiction of Incidental Matters. Allowance pendente lite. Remedy Thereon. The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court has exclusive jurisdiction in divorce, and of all incidental matters arising therein. An action at law cannot be maintained for an allowance pendente lite in a petition for divorce. Such a decree, being interlocutory, and subject to change, cannot be the foundation of an action as upon a final judgment.

ASSUMPSIT for allowance made to plaintiff for her support during the pendency of a petition for divorce. Certified from the Common Pleas Division, and heard on demurrer to declaration.

Dennis J. Holland, for plaintiff.

Franklin P. Owen and John P. Beagan, for defendant.


By Gen. Laws R.I. cap. 222, § 4, cap. 195, § 14, exclusive jurisdiction in divorce and incidental matters arising therein is vested in the Appellate Division of this court. We are of the opinion, therefore, that no action can be maintained in any other court to recover an allowance made to a wife for her support during the pendency of the petition for divorce, but that recourse must be had to the remedies prescribed by the rule of this Division.

Moreover, a decree for an allowance pendente lite is an interlocutory decree, subject to revocation or modification at any time by the court which made it, and consequently cannot be the foundation of an action as upon a final judgment. 4 Wait's Actions and Defences, 187, § 5.


Summaries of

Vine v. Vine

Supreme Court of Rhode Island. PROVIDENCE
Feb 10, 1899
21 R.I. 190 (R.I. 1899)
Case details for

Vine v. Vine

Case Details

Full title:SARAH L. VINE vs. GEORGE VINE

Court:Supreme Court of Rhode Island. PROVIDENCE

Date published: Feb 10, 1899

Citations

21 R.I. 190 (R.I. 1899)
42 A. 871

Citing Cases

Grattage v. Superior Court

In the cases cited the court based its action on the broad construction of the statute by which alimony was…

Asadoorian

Failure to pay the allowance is fundamentally contempt of the court's decree. One in default may be proceeded…