From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Vander Shiver v. State

Supreme Court of Florida, Division A
Dec 11, 1931
138 So. 502 (Fla. 1931)

Opinion

Opinion filed December 11, 1931.

A writ of error to the Circuit Court for Calhoun County; Amos Lewis, Judge.

Affirmed.

H. V. McClellan, for Plaintiff in Error;

Cary D. Landis, Atty. Gen. and Roy Campbell, Asst. for Defendant in Error.


This case comes on writ of error to the Circuit Court of Calhoun County wherein the plaintiff in error was convicted of the larceny of a cow.

The assignment of error attack the sufficiency of the evidence to sustain the verdict and judgment. The principal contention is that the ownership of the property in Suggs as laid in the indictment was not proven.

This Court has repeatedly held that where an indictment lays the ownership of stolen property in a particular person and it is shown that the particular person was in the lawful custody of the property and entitled to its possession, there is no material variance between the allegations and proof. See Parker vs. State, 75 Fla. 541, 78 So. 980; Mathews vs. State, 85 Fla. 194, 95 So. 609, and cases there cited.

It appears that the defendant attempted to defend on the trial upon the theory that Suggs, the alleged owner, had given him, defendant, permission to sell and dispose of the cow in question and he testified to such a state of facts. Suggs denied the existence of any such facts. The jury evidently believed Suggs and resolved that a conflict. in the testimony against the defendant, in which action the jury was within its proper evidence.

No reversible error appearing in the record, the judgment should be affirmed and it is so ordered.

Affirmed.

ELLIS AND BROWN, J.J., concur.

WHITFIELD, P.J., AND TERRELL AND DAVIS, J.J., concur in the opinion and judgment.


Summaries of

Vander Shiver v. State

Supreme Court of Florida, Division A
Dec 11, 1931
138 So. 502 (Fla. 1931)
Case details for

Vander Shiver v. State

Case Details

Full title:VANDER SHIVER, Plaintiff in Error, v. THE STATE OF FLORIDA, Defendant in…

Court:Supreme Court of Florida, Division A

Date published: Dec 11, 1931

Citations

138 So. 502 (Fla. 1931)
138 So. 502

Citing Cases

Leo v. State

Although the holdings of Pelaez and Gray seem not to have been explicitly receded from, their force is…

Jones v. State

Affirmed. See Shiver v. State, 103 Fla. 871, 138 So. 502 (1931); Cortes v. State, 135 Fla. 589, 185 So. 323…