From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Town of New Chicago v. First State Bank

Court of Appeals of Indiana
Dec 6, 1929
90 Ind. App. 643 (Ind. Ct. App. 1929)

Opinion

No. 13,526.

Filed December 6, 1929. Rehearing denied January 28, 1930.

1. JUDGMENTS — Life of Judgment — Execution May be Issued after 10 Years — Action May be Maintained within 20 Years. — A judgment is not dead after 10 years from the date of its rendition, for § 744 Burns 1926 provides for the issuing of an execution by leave of court after 10 years, and an action may be maintained on a judgment at any time within 20 years. p. 644.

2. JUDGMENTS — Action On — No Conditions Precedent. — The law does not require that any steps be taken either to revive the lien of a judgment on real estate or to enforce payment of the judgment as a condition precedent to maintaining an action of debt on such judgment. p. 644.

3. JUDGMENTS — Action On — Where May be Maintained. — A judgment is a debt of record, upon which an action may be maintained either in the court which rendered such judgment or in any other court of competent jurisdiction. p. 644.

4. JUDGMENTS — Action On — Renewal Action on Judgment Obtained — Limitation on Renewal Action. — A judgment plaintiff may maintain an action on the judgment, and obtain a new judgment thereon, and he may renew his action ad infinitum on each succeeding judgment thus recovered, provided the action is commenced within the 20-year period of limitation. p. 644.

From Lake Superior Court; Charles E. Greenwald, Judge.

Action by the First State Bank of Hobart against the town of New Chicago. From a judgment for plaintiff, the defendant appealed. Affirmed. By the court in banc.

Dominic P. Sevald, Mariann K. Sevald and Frank J. Cook, for appellant.

E.J. Call and Kenneth Call, for appellee.


On June 25, 1914, appellee recovered three separate judgments in the Lake Circuit Court against appellant. No execution was issued on any of said judgments, nor was any proceeding had to collect said judgments until May 15, 1928, when appellee filed this action in Room 3 Lake Superior Court on a complaint in three paragraphs on the three separate judgments rendered in the Lake Circuit Court, June 25, 1914.

Appellant contends that, whereas no execution was issued on said judgments nor any attempt made to collect the same, and no suit at law having been instituted on said judgments within 10 years after their rendition, said judgments were "dead."

That a judgment is not dead after 10 years from the date of its rendition is evident, for § 744 Burns 1926 authorizes the issuing of an execution by leave of court first obtained as 1. provided in said section, and another section of the statute provides that an action may be maintained on a judgment at any time within 20 years (§ 302 Burns 1926).

The laws of Indiana do not require that any steps whatever be taken either to revive the lien of a judgment on real estate or to enforce the payment of the judgment as a condition 2-4. precedent to maintaining an action of debt on that judgment. A judgment is a debt of record, upon which an action may be maintained, either in the court which rendered such judgment or in any other court of competent jurisdiction, and the judgment plaintiff may renew his action ad infinitum upon each successive judgment thus recovered, provided the action is brought any time within the 20-year period of limitation. Gould v. Hayden (1878), 63 Ind. 443; Palmer v. Glover (1881), 73 Ind. 529; Heinl v. City of Terre Haute (1903), 161 Ind. 44, 66 N.E. 450. Any other construction would nullify the statute.

Judgment affirmed.


Summaries of

Town of New Chicago v. First State Bank

Court of Appeals of Indiana
Dec 6, 1929
90 Ind. App. 643 (Ind. Ct. App. 1929)
Case details for

Town of New Chicago v. First State Bank

Case Details

Full title:TOWN OF NEW CHICAGO v. FIRST STATE BANK OF HOBART

Court:Court of Appeals of Indiana

Date published: Dec 6, 1929

Citations

90 Ind. App. 643 (Ind. Ct. App. 1929)
169 N.E. 56

Citing Cases

Trinity EMS, Inc. v. Coombs

Compare RSA 508:5 (2010) ("Actions of debt upon judgments, recognizances, and contracts under seal may be…

Lewis v. Rex Metal Craft, Inc.

A judgment is a debt of record, created by decree of a court, upon which an action may be maintained. Dock v.…