From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Tiller v. Tiller

Supreme Court of Arizona
Jun 3, 1965
98 Ariz. 156 (Ariz. 1965)

Opinion

No. 8484.

June 3, 1965.

Appeal from the Superior Court, Pima County, Lee Garrett, J.

Douglas C. Howard, Tucson, for appellant.

No appearance for appellee.


This is an appeal in a divorce action wherein the appellant, Lucille Tiller, was the plaintiff and the appellee, Sam Tiller, was the defendant, the plaintiff having received a judgment of divorce which incorporated and adopted a property settlement made by the parties. Subsequently a controversy arose regarding the nature of the payments to be made to the wife as result of the property settlement and the subsequent judgment incorporating the settlement. Appellant contends that the order is enforceable by contempt proceedings. The appellee contends that the payments were a contractual obligation and therefore not enforceable by contempt. The trial judge held for the appellee.

Appellant has raised several errors challenging the judgment of the trial court. Appellee has not favored us with a brief and this case has been submitted for decision under Rule 7(a)2, Rules of the Supreme Court, 17 A.R.S. As there are debatable issues this Court will assume that the failure to file an answering brief is a confession of reversible error on the part of the appellee. Wilson v. Wilson, 94 Ariz. 353, 385 P.2d 226 (1963); Siemers v. Randall, 94 Ariz. 302, 383 P.2d 753 (1963); Barrett v. Hiney, 94 Ariz. 133, 382 P.2d 240 (1963); Tom v. Baca, 93 Ariz. 96, 378 P.2d 912 (1963); Nelson v. Nelson, 91 Ariz. 215, 370 P.2d 952 (1962); Stover v. Kesmar, 84 Ariz. 387, 329 P.2d 1107 (1958); Dowding v. Smithers, 82 Ariz. 261, 311 P.2d 967 (1957).

Judgment reversed.

LOCKWOOD, C.J., STRUCKMEYER, V.C.J., and BERNSTEIN and McFARLAND, JJ., concurring.


Summaries of

Tiller v. Tiller

Supreme Court of Arizona
Jun 3, 1965
98 Ariz. 156 (Ariz. 1965)
Case details for

Tiller v. Tiller

Case Details

Full title:Lucille TILLER, Appellant, v. Sam D. TILLER, Appellee

Court:Supreme Court of Arizona

Date published: Jun 3, 1965

Citations

98 Ariz. 156 (Ariz. 1965)
402 P.2d 573

Citing Cases

Mayberry v. Stambaugh

And in the last supreme court case to directly address this issue, the court stated that because "there are…

Luna v. Peinado

If an appeal raises debatable issues and there appears to be no good cause for the appellee's failure to…