From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Stinson v. Taylor

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine. Kennebec
Jul 23, 1942
27 A.2d 400 (Me. 1942)

Opinion

Opinion, July 23, 1942.

Proceedings Necessary to Enforce Wage Rates Established by Wage Board.

When the Commissioner of Labor fails to comply with the statutory provisions in regard to the enforcement of wages established by a Wage Board, the Justice of the Superior Court is without jurisdiction in the case.

ON APPEAL.

An action was brought by the Commissioner of Labor to enforce wage rates established by the Wage Board acting for the establishment of wages in the Industry of Packing of Fish and Fish Products. The Commissioner failed to follow the procedure provided by statute as a condition precedent to the maintenance of such action. Decision by the Justice of the Superior Court was for the Commissioner. Defendant appealed. Held that because of such failure by the Commissioner the Justice of the Superior Court was without jurisdiction. Appeal was sustained and the case remanded for dismissal for want of jurisdiction. The case fully appears in the opinion.

Blaisdell Blaisdell, for petitioner-appellant.

Frank I. Cowan, Attorney General, John S. S. Fessenden, for the Commissioner of Labor.

SITTING: STURGIS, C. J., THAXTER, HUDSON, MANSER, WORSTER, MURCHIE, JJ.


Appeal from the decision of a Justice of the Superior Court in an action brought by the Commissioner of Labor and Industry of this State to enforce the minimum fair wage rates established by the Wage Board for women and minors employed in the Industry of Packing of Fish and Fish Products.

Under Section 12 of Chapter 289 Public Laws, 1939, by which this proceeding is authorized, it is provided that the Commissioner of Labor and Industry as conditions precedent to the maintenance of an action to enforce minimum fair wage rates established for this Industry shall file in the office of the clerk of the Superior Court for Kennebec County the record of hearing before the Wage Board, together with its report, findings and determinations as filed with the Commissioner and his certificate of service thereof on each employer in this state of whom he has information or record. Here neither the record of hearing before the Wage Board nor the certificate of service on employers by the Commissioner of Labor and Industry have been filed. For this failure to comply with the statute the Justice of the Superior Court from whose decision appeal is taken was without jurisdiction and the proceeding before him was a nullity. Stinson, Apl't. v. Commissioner of Labor, 137 Me. 332, 334, 17 A.2d 760.

On this record without a consideration of other questions raised by the appeal the mandate is

Appeal sustained. Case remanded for dismissal for want of jurisdiction.


Summaries of

Stinson v. Taylor

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine. Kennebec
Jul 23, 1942
27 A.2d 400 (Me. 1942)
Case details for

Stinson v. Taylor

Case Details

Full title:CALVIN L. STINSON, APPELLANT, vs. JESSE W. TAYLOR, COMMISSIONER OF LABOR…

Court:Supreme Judicial Court of Maine. Kennebec

Date published: Jul 23, 1942

Citations

27 A.2d 400 (Me. 1942)
27 A.2d 400