From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State v. Guerrero

Oregon Supreme Court
Jun 3, 1966
415 P.2d 28 (Or. 1966)

Opinion

Argued at Pendleton May 2, 1966

Affirmed June 3, 1966

Appeal from Circuit Court, Deschutes County.

ROBERT H. FOLEY, Judge.

AFFIRMED.

Oscar D. Howlett, Portland, argued the cause and filed a brief for appellant.

Louis Selken, District Attorney, Bend, argued the cause and filed a brief for respondent.

Before McALLISTER, Chief Justice, and PERRY, SLOAN, GOODWIN, DENECKE, HOLMAN and LUSK, Justices.


IN BANC


Defendant was convicted of attempted burglary not in a dwelling. He appeals.

He was apprehended while endeavoring to enter a drug store in Bend. He was searched and a plastic case containing an eye dropper and needles of the kind commonly used by drug addicts was found on his person. These were introduced in evidence at defendant's trial over his objection. This is the only claim of error in the appeal. Defendant claims that the prejudice to him outweighed the probative value of the evidence.

In State v. Kristich, 1961, 226 Or. 240, 359 P.2d 1106, we held that evidence which may indicate the commission of a crime other than the one for which a defendant is charged is admissible if it has probative relevance to the case and its prejudice is not out of proportion to its value. See State v. Flett, 234 Or. 124, 380 P.2d 634 for further exposition of the rule. In the instant case the state claimed that the evidence tended to show a motive for attempting to burglarize a drug store. We agree.

The evidence did not suggest the commission of another crime. But it did degrade defendant as a probable narcotics user. To that extent the evidence was prejudicial. Nevertheless, it also established a compelling motive for defendant to attempt to enter a drug store. Accordingly, the evidence had real probative value and it was proper to have admitted it.

Affirmed.


Summaries of

State v. Guerrero

Oregon Supreme Court
Jun 3, 1966
415 P.2d 28 (Or. 1966)
Case details for

State v. Guerrero

Case Details

Full title:STATE OF OREGON v. GUERRERO

Court:Oregon Supreme Court

Date published: Jun 3, 1966

Citations

415 P.2d 28 (Or. 1966)
415 P.2d 28

Citing Cases

State v. Ralph

It cannot be shown to be "good" or "bad," but is simply a medical fact. Likewise, it is not a crime or civil…

State v. Pruitt

Admission of this testimony is the basis of the first assignment of error. The state contends it is relevant…