From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State v. Essary

The Supreme Court of Washington. Department Two
Oct 25, 1962
60 Wn. 2d 731 (Wash. 1962)

Opinion

No. 36669.

October 25, 1962.

CRIMINAL LAW — SENTENCE — SUSPENDED SENTENCE — REVOCATION — JUSTICE COURTS. A justice court is empowered by RCW 9.92.060 to suspend a jail sentence "until otherwise ordered by such court", and such a suspension may be revoked without notice or hearing even though such right was not expressly reserved, and even though the period covered by the sentence has expired.

See Am. Jur., Criminal Law §§ 479, 499.

Certiorari to review a judgment of the Superior Court for King County, No. 586832, James W. Hodson, J., entered July 13, 1962. Affirmed.

The defendant, after having the suspension of a justice court sentence revoked, seeks review of a superior court judgment dismissing a writ of habeas corpus.

W.L. Delbridge, for relator.

Charles O. Carroll and James E. Kennedy, for respondent.



The relator, by a writ of certiorari seeks review of a judgment dismissing a writ of habeas corpus. He was convicted on November 29, 1960, by C.R. Norris, a non-lawyer Justice of the Peace in King County, Washington, on a charge of driving a motor vehicle upon the highway of the state of Washington while his license was suspended. He was, among other penalties, sentenced to serve 180 days in jail, with 170 days suspended.

The right to revoke the suspension without notice and without a hearing was not reserved in the judgment and sentence.

Thereafter in April 1962, the relator was charged in the Justice Court of C.R. Norris with driving a motor vehicle upon the highway of the state of Washington while his license was suspended. He obtained a change of venue on that charge from the court of C.R. Norris to the county seat. In July 1962, he was found guilty of the latter charge; and thereafter C.R. Norris revoked, without notice and without hearing, the suspended sentence and ordered that the relator be confined in the county jail to serve the remaining 170 days.

The relator contends that the court of C.R. Norris was without jurisdiction to revoke the suspended sentence, since it failed to expressly reserve in the judgment the right to revoke without notice and without a hearing.

[1] The power of the Justice Court to suspend a jail sentence is clearly established under RCW 9.92.060. State ex rel. Graham v. Willey, 168 Wn. 340, 12 P.2d 393. The statute provides that a jail sentence may be "suspended until otherwise ordered by such court."

In State v. Davis, 56 Wn.2d 729, 355 P.2d 344, it was held that the suspended sentence may be revoked even though the period covered by the sentence has expired. This rule has been adhered to by this court in State ex rel. Pence v. Koch, 173 Wn. 420, 23 P.2d 884; State ex rel. Tingstad v. Starwich, 119 Wn. 561, 206 P. 29, 26 A.L.R. 393.

The judgment is affirmed.


Summaries of

State v. Essary

The Supreme Court of Washington. Department Two
Oct 25, 1962
60 Wn. 2d 731 (Wash. 1962)
Case details for

State v. Essary

Case Details

Full title:THE STATE OF WASHINGTON, Plaintiff, v. GRADY ESSARY, Defendant and…

Court:The Supreme Court of Washington. Department Two

Date published: Oct 25, 1962

Citations

60 Wn. 2d 731 (Wash. 1962)
60 Wash. 2d 731
375 P.2d 486