From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State Highway Comm. v. Stockhoff

Oregon Court of Appeals
Sep 4, 1974
524 P.2d 1240 (Or. Ct. App. 1974)

Opinion

No. 21342

Original opinion argued January 25, 1974

Affirmed March 18, 1974 Mandate recalled May 30, 1974 Modified July 29, 1974 Petition for review denied September 4, 1974 See original opinion Vol. 16 Or. App. 647

Appeal from Circuit Court, Union County.

W. F. BROWNTON, Judge.

George H. Corey, Steven H. Corey, and Corey, Byler Rew, Pendleton, for petition.

No appearance contra.

Before SCHWAB, Chief Judge, and FORT and TANZER, Judges.


MANDATE MODIFIED.


Respondents petitioned for review contending that we erred in denying their motion for attorney fees on appeal in this condemnation case.

Attorney fees are available to a successful litigant only when so provided by the Constitution or by statute. The rule applies with full force to condemnation suits. Multnomah County v. Burbank, 235 Or. 616, 618, 386 P.2d 444 (1963).

This suit was commenced on June 28, 1971. Defendants point to former ORS 366.380 (9), applicable to actions commenced prior to September 9, 1971, as the statutory source of the court's authority to award attorney fees on appeal. That section, however, applies to attorney fees for trial. Highway Commission v. Hursh, 245 Or. 378, 422 P.2d 266 (1966). No other statutes authorize such fees and the constitutional prohibitions against public taking, Art. I, § 18, and Art. XI, § 4, Oregon Constitution, do not of themselves authorize such fees. Re Petition of Reeder, 110 Or. 484, 495, 222 P. 724 (1924).

The mandate will issue without provision of reasonable attorney fees.


Summaries of

State Highway Comm. v. Stockhoff

Oregon Court of Appeals
Sep 4, 1974
524 P.2d 1240 (Or. Ct. App. 1974)
Case details for

State Highway Comm. v. Stockhoff

Case Details

Full title:STATE HIGHWAY COMMISSION, Appellant, v. STOCKHOFF ET AL, Respondents

Court:Oregon Court of Appeals

Date published: Sep 4, 1974

Citations

524 P.2d 1240 (Or. Ct. App. 1974)
524 P.2d 1240

Citing Cases

Highway Comm. v. Boothman

After defendants had completed their case-in-chief, the state's attorney offered to stipulate that the…

Douglas County v. Brown

Allowance of attorney fees is purely a matter of statute. See Highway Com. v. Stockhoff, 18 Or. App. 233, 524…