From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State ex Rel. McDougall v. Martone

Supreme Court of Arizona
Apr 27, 1993
174 Ariz. 343 (Ariz. 1993)

Opinion

No. CV-92-0467-PR.

April 27, 1993.


ORDER

The Court granted review of this case on February 17, 1993, it was argued to the Court on April 15, 1993, and thereafter considered in conference.

Chief Justice Feldman and Justice Zlaket concluded that the Court of Appeals erred in its analysis and disposition and voted to vacate the Court of Appeals' opinion and affirm the Superior Court judge's order. Vice Chief Justice Moeller and Justice Corcoran would affirm the magistrate's order and thus merely vacate the grant of review as improvident. Justice Martone, who was the Superior Court judge in this case, recused himself and did not participate in the determination of this matter.

There being no majority,

IT IS ORDERED that the February 17, 1993 order granting review is vacated and the Petition for Review is dismissed.


Summaries of

State ex Rel. McDougall v. Martone

Supreme Court of Arizona
Apr 27, 1993
174 Ariz. 343 (Ariz. 1993)
Case details for

State ex Rel. McDougall v. Martone

Case Details

Full title:STATE of Arizona ex rel. Roderick G. McDOUGALL, Phoenix City Attorney…

Court:Supreme Court of Arizona

Date published: Apr 27, 1993

Citations

174 Ariz. 343 (Ariz. 1993)
849 P.2d 1373

Citing Cases

State v. Love

We ultimately were forced to dismiss it because the remaining four justices were equally divided on the issue…

Hazine v. Montgomery Elevator Co.

In retrospect, it would have been advisable, when it became known that a split on a court in transition was…