From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State ex rel. Burk v. Judge of the Superior Court

Supreme Court of Indiana
Sep 18, 1967
248 Ind. 394 (Ind. 1967)

Opinion

No. 31,119.

Filed September 18, 1967.

MANDAMUS AND PROHIBITION — Rules of the Supreme Court — Rule 2-36 — Return on Writ. — The respondent may file a verified return showing only reason why the writ should not be obeyed. No other pleading on behalf of a respondent will be entertained.

Original action by Dorothy J. Burk to compel the Madison Superior Court, No. 2, to make a panel from which a special judge could be selected.

Writ made permanent.

Peck Peck and William L. Peck, both of Anderson, for the Relator.

Charles B. Salyer and Ralph F. Mattingly, both of Anderson, for the Respondents.


On February 20, 1967, we issued an alternative writ of mandate commanding the respondents to rule on the relator's petition to make a panel from which a special judge can be selected to try cause No. 2S 65-542 in the respondent court entitled Chesley T. Burk v. Dorothy J. Burk, or on the failure to do so, to file their return showing any reason in law or in fact why this writ should not be made permanent on or before the 23rd day of March, 1967. On April 4, 1967, we issued a second writ of mandate commanding the respondents to expunge from the records in the above cause the nunc pro tunc record made on February 20, 1967, and the purported judgment filed on February 24, 1967, and dated December 30, 1965, or on the failure to do so, to file their return showing any reason in law or in fact why this writ should not be made permanent on or before the 11th day of April, 1967.

Respondents have filed returns to the alternative writs, but they do not comply with the rules of this Court as they are not verified. Rule 2-36 of this Court provides in part:

"Within the time allowed, the respondent may file . . . a verified return showing any reason . . . why the writ should not be obeyed. No other pleading on behalf of a respondent will be entertained." (Emphasis supplied). The alternative writs are made permanent and absolute.

NOTE. — Reported in 229 N.E.2d 639.


Summaries of

State ex rel. Burk v. Judge of the Superior Court

Supreme Court of Indiana
Sep 18, 1967
248 Ind. 394 (Ind. 1967)
Case details for

State ex rel. Burk v. Judge of the Superior Court

Case Details

Full title:STATE OF INDIANA ON THE RELATION OF BURK v. THE JUDGE OF THE SUPERIOR…

Court:Supreme Court of Indiana

Date published: Sep 18, 1967

Citations

248 Ind. 394 (Ind. 1967)
229 N.E.2d 639

Citing Cases

State ex rel. State Board of Tax Commission v. Daviess Circuit Court

ARTERBURN, J. Relator contends that since the response was not verified it is entitled automatically to the…