From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Southerland v. Crump

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Mar 1, 1928
142 S.E. 7 (N.C. 1928)

Opinion

(Filed 14 March, 1928.)

Contracts — Action — Plaintiff Musts show Performance in Order to Recover.

To recover an express contract with decedent for personal services rendered him prior to his death. plaintiff must show performance on his part.

APPEAL by plaintiff from Cranmer, J., at August Term, 1927, of DUPLIN. Affirmed.

Oscar B. Turner for plaintiff.

H. D. Williams, Geo. R. Ward and W. H. Weatherspoon for defendant.


Action to recover upon an express contract alleged to have been entered into by and between plaintiff and the testator of defendant for services rendered by plaintiff to said testator.

From judgment dismissing the action, upon for nonsuit, at close of all the evidence, plaintiff appealed to the Supreme Court.


Conceding that there was some evidence tending to sustain plaintiff's allegation of an express contract by which defendant's testator agreed to pay plaintiff for services to be rendered to him by plaintiff, there was no error in the judgment dismissing the action, at the close of all the evidence, under C. S., 567. There was no evidence tending to show performance by plaintiff of the alleged contract.

In the absence of such evidence, plaintiff cannot recover in this action. The judgment is

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Southerland v. Crump

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Mar 1, 1928
142 S.E. 7 (N.C. 1928)
Case details for

Southerland v. Crump

Case Details

Full title:C. S. SOUTHERLAND v. W. T. CRUMP, EXECUTOR OF J. A. SOUTHERLAND, DECEASED

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Mar 1, 1928

Citations

142 S.E. 7 (N.C. 1928)
142 S.E. 7

Citing Cases

Southerland v. Crump

The former action in this cause, by an opinion of the Supreme Court filed 14 March, 1928, upon motion for…