From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Sitton v. Evans

Supreme Court of Georgia
Mar 28, 1949
52 S.E.2d 599 (Ga. 1949)

Opinion

16546.

MARCH 16, 1949. REHEARING DENIED MARCH 28, 1949.

Mandamus. Before Judge Guess. DeKalb Superior Court. December 23, 1948.

Lucian J. Endicott, for plaintiff.

J. A. McCurdy, for defendant.


1. Until there has been a judgment in the trial court finally disposing of a cause, this court is without jurisdiction to entertain a writ of error complaining of a judgment overruling a demurrer to the answer. Fugazzi v. Tomlinson, 119 Ga. 622 ( 46 S.E. 831); Bozeman v. Ward-Truitt Co., 141 Ga. 45 ( 80 S.E. 320); Vanzant v. First National Bank of Polk County, 164 Ga. 772 (2-a) ( 139 S.E. 537); Miller Service v. Miller, 201 Ga. 344 ( 39 S.E.2d 750).

2. In a mandamus case, such as this, where the plaintiff demurred to the answer and this demurrer was overruled, and the record is silent as to what judgment, if any, was entered in the main cause, the recitation in the bill of exceptions, "that if said order and judgment of said judge had been favorable to said plaintiff, instead of adverse to him and said demurrer had been sustained, same would have resulted in a final dismissal and termination of said case, and therefore is proper subject-matter of a direct bill of exceptions to the Supreme Court of Georgia," is a legally impossible conclusion, since, had the judgment been rendered as contended by the plaintiff, it would have resulted only in the dismissal of the answer, and would have left the main cause pending in the court below for determination of the question as to whether the mandamus should be made absolute. The writ of error is, therefore, premature. Irby v. Irby, 167 Ga. 708 ( 146 S.E. 489).

Writ of error dismissed. All the Justices concur.

No. 16546. MARCH 16, 1949. REHEARING DENIED MARCH 28, 1949.


Summaries of

Sitton v. Evans

Supreme Court of Georgia
Mar 28, 1949
52 S.E.2d 599 (Ga. 1949)
Case details for

Sitton v. Evans

Case Details

Full title:SITTON v. EVANS, HEALTH OFFICER

Court:Supreme Court of Georgia

Date published: Mar 28, 1949

Citations

52 S.E.2d 599 (Ga. 1949)
52 S.E.2d 599

Citing Cases

Shropshire, v. Broome

The judgment overruling demurrers to a caveat filed to the probate of a will in solemn form is not a final…

Grogan v. Bank of Acworth

1. No cause shall be carried to the Supreme Court upon any bill of exceptions while it is pending in the…