From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Richmond County Hospital Authority v. McClain

Supreme Court of Georgia
May 18, 1965
143 S.E.2d 165 (Ga. 1965)

Opinion

22972.

ARGUED MAY 11, 1965.

DECIDED MAY 18, 1965.

Question certified by the Court of Appeals of Georgia.

Gould B. Hagler, for plaintiff in error.

Harris, Chance, McCracken Harrison, Henry T. Chance, Henderson, Salley Cushman, Julian B. Salley, Jr., contra.


The sole ruling which the bill of exceptions seeks to have reviewed and which the Court of Appeals has certified to this court for answer is a judgment by the trial judge holding that a hospital authority created under the Act of 1941 (Ga. L. 1941, p. 241) is an employer within the meaning of Code Ann. § 114-101 for the purpose of workmen's compensation. In fact, the question certified for answer is the only issue in the case. The Constitution of this State confers exclusive jurisdiction on the Court of Appeals and not upon the Supreme Court to review such cases ( Code §§ 2-3704, 2-3708), and an answer by the Supreme Court to the question certified would constitute a decision of the entire case by this court instead of the Court of Appeals. Under the Constitution this cannot be done. Gunby v. Roberts, 205 Ga. 346 ( 53 S.E.2d 370), and citations. For the reasons stated we must respectfully decline to answer the question certified.

Question not answered. All the Justices concur.

ARGUED MAY 11, 1965 — DECIDED MAY 18, 1965.


The Court of Appeals (in case No. 41240) certified to this court the following question:

"Is a hospital authority created under the provision of Code Chapter 99-15 (Acts 1941, page 241 et seq.) an employer within the meaning of Code § 114-101 for the purposes of workmen's compensation?"


Summaries of

Richmond County Hospital Authority v. McClain

Supreme Court of Georgia
May 18, 1965
143 S.E.2d 165 (Ga. 1965)
Case details for

Richmond County Hospital Authority v. McClain

Case Details

Full title:RICHMOND COUNTY HOSPITAL AUTHORITY v. McCLAIN

Court:Supreme Court of Georgia

Date published: May 18, 1965

Citations

143 S.E.2d 165 (Ga. 1965)
143 S.E.2d 165

Citing Cases

In re Interest of J.F.

See, e.g., Lawrence v. State , 268 Ga. 420, 420, 489 S.E.2d 850 (1997) ("The questions certified seek…