From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Resner v. Northern Pacific Railway

Supreme Court of Montana
Mar 25, 1974
520 P.2d 655 (Mont. 1974)

Opinion

No. 12669.

Decided March 25, 1974.

Appeal from the District Court of Mineral County. Fourth Judicial District. Hon. Jack L. Green, Judge presiding.

Daniel Shea (argued), Missoula, for plaintiff.

Garlington, Lohn Robinson, Missoula, Lawrence F. Daly (argued), Missoula, for defendant.


ORDER


Defendant's motion to dismiss plaintiff's appeal is granted. Reason: The district court's computation of interest in its amended judgment of February 21, 1973, is correct. Authority: Stockton Theatres, Inc., v. Palermo, 55 Cal.2d 439, 11 Cal.Rptr. 580, 582, 360 P.2d 76, specifically the following rule: "* * * when a judgment is reversed on appeal the new award subsequently entered by the trial court can bear interest only from the date of entry of such new judgment." Rationale: As tort claims do not bear interest until the amount of damages is determined by judgment, the additional award of $65,759.51 bears interest only from the date of the judgment therefor, February 21, 1973.

Defendant's motion to assess damages against plaintiff for a frivolous appeal is denied. Reason: We choose not to exercise this discretionary power in this case as these successive appeals and applications are, in our view, the product of misdirected efforts flowing from the misguided judgment of plaintiff's counsel.


Summaries of

Resner v. Northern Pacific Railway

Supreme Court of Montana
Mar 25, 1974
520 P.2d 655 (Mont. 1974)
Case details for

Resner v. Northern Pacific Railway

Case Details

Full title:CHAROLETTE L. RESNER, ADMINISTRATRIX OF THE ESTATE OF HERBERT R. RESNER…

Court:Supreme Court of Montana

Date published: Mar 25, 1974

Citations

520 P.2d 655 (Mont. 1974)
520 P.2d 655

Citing Cases

Sun River Cattle v. Miners' Bank

Clearly, we held the defendant bank became liable on each of the six checks because of its statutory duty to…

Long v. Hendricks

Undee these circumstances we cannot say that, as a matter of law, the sum was ascertainable prior to the…