From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Reed v. Lavender Bros

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Feb 1, 1934
175 S.E. 927 (N.C. 1934)

Opinion

(Filed 28 February, 1934.)

Master and Servant F i —

An award of the Industrial Commission is conclusive and binding as to all questions of fact when supported by sufficient, competent evidence, N.C. Code, 8081 (ppp), and neither the Supreme Court nor the Superior Court can consider the evidence for the purpose of determining the facts on appeal.

APPEAL by defendants from Sinclair, J., at September Term, 1933, of ROBESON.

Johnson Floyd for plaintiff.

Ralph V. Kidd for defendants.


Proceeding under Workmen's Compensation Act to determine liability of defendants to dependents or next of kin of Lawrence Reed, deceased employee.

From an award by the hearing commissioner, which was adopted and approved by the full Commission, and affirmed on appeal to the Superior Court, the defendants again appeal.


The award was properly entered upon the facts found by the hearing commissioner, later adopted and approved by the full Commission, as they are amply supported by the evidence.

It is well settled that the award of the Industrial Commission is "conclusive and binding as to all questions of fact," if supported by sufficient competent evidence. N.C. Code, sec. 8081 (ppp); Clark v. Woolen Mills, 204 N.C. 529, 168 S.E. 816; Massey v. Board of Education, 204 N.C. 193, 167 S.E. 695; Kenan v. Motor Co., 203 N.C. 108, 164 S.E. 729. Indeed, neither this Court nor the Superior Court, on appeal from an award of the Industrial Commission, can consider the evidence and determine therefrom what the facts are. This is a matter exclusively for the Industrial Commission. Ussery v. Cotton Mills, 201 N.C. 688, 161 S.E. 307.

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Reed v. Lavender Bros

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Feb 1, 1934
175 S.E. 927 (N.C. 1934)
Case details for

Reed v. Lavender Bros

Case Details

Full title:LAWRENCE REED v. LAVENDER BROTHERS ET AL

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Feb 1, 1934

Citations

175 S.E. 927 (N.C. 1934)
175 S.E. 927

Citing Cases

Thomason v. Cab Co.

Henry v. Leather Co., 231 N.C. 477, 57 S.E.2d 760. The Superior Court cannot consider the evidence in the…

Thomas v. Gas Co.

We may concede that dependency may in some instances become a mixed question of fact and law. Re: Carroll…