From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Penland v. Gowan

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Nov 1, 1948
50 S.E.2d 182 (N.C. 1948)

Opinion

(Filed 10 November, 1948.)

Appeal and Error § 31e —

Where an election sought to be enjoined has been held, an appeal from judgment denying injunctive relief against the holding of the election will be dismissed, since the questions sought to be presented by the appeal have become academic.

APPEAL by plaintiffs from Moore, J., September Term, 1948, McDOWELL.

John C. Cheesborough and George Sandlin for plaintiff appellants.

Proctor Dameron for defendant appellees.


Civil action for writ of injunction to restrain the holding of a special election under Chap. 1084, Session Laws, 1947.

When the cause came on for hearing in the court below, trial by jury was waived and the cause was submitted to the judge with full authority to hear the evidence, find the facts, and enter judgment upon the facts found. The court, after finding the facts, entered judgment denying the injunctive relief prayed and dismissing the action. Plaintiffs excepted and appealed.


A careful examination of the pleadings in this cause discloses that a writ of injunction is the only relief sought by plaintiffs. The only issue of fact raised in the pleadings is directed to the right of the plaintiffs to this relief. The election they seek to enjoin was held 31 August, 1948, and is now an accomplished fact. Hence, the questions plaintiffs seek to present on this appeal are academic. For that reason, the appeal is dismissed on authority of Eller v. Wall, ante, 359, and the cases there cited.

Appeal dismissed.


Summaries of

Penland v. Gowan

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Nov 1, 1948
50 S.E.2d 182 (N.C. 1948)
Case details for

Penland v. Gowan

Case Details

Full title:L. J. PENLAND, BRUCE COWAN AND FORES "PAINTER v. TOM GOWAN, CHAIRMAN, WILL…

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Nov 1, 1948

Citations

50 S.E.2d 182 (N.C. 1948)
50 S.E.2d 182

Citing Cases

Ratcliff v. Rodman

The sole relief sought by plaintiff is the issuance of a writ of mandamus requiring the Beaufort County Board…

Green v. Briggs

The election held on 28 February, 1956, resulted in the prohibition of the sale of beer and wine in Davidson…