From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Nagle v. Rutledge

U.S.
Jan 1, 1879
100 U.S. 675 (1879)

Opinion

OCTOBER TERM, 1879.

This court has no jurisdiction to review the judgment of the Supreme Court of the Territory of Wyoming, unless the record shows that the matter actually in dispute exceeds $1,000.

Mr. Edward P. Johnson for the defendant in error, in support of the motion.

Mr. W.R. Steele, contra.


MOTION to dismiss a writ of error to the Supreme Court of the Territory of Wyoming.

The facts are stated in the opinion of the court.


To give us jurisdiction in cases coming from the Supreme Court of the Territory of Wyoming, the value of the matter in dispute must exceed $1,000. This writ of error was sued out by the defendant below on a judgment against him for only $969.63. It is claimed we have jurisdiction, however, because the defendant in his answer set up a counter claim for $1,340. The only question presented here on that branch of the case is whether the plaintiff below was liable for interest on a note of $210, at the rate of three per cent a month from the twenty-fourth day of June, 1872, until the date of the judgment, July 26, 1876, or for some shorter period. In no event could the amount thus put in controversy reach $1,000; and since if error should be found in the charge of the court on this claim, it would only result in a reduction of the judgment as it now stands, and not in an actual money recovery in favor of the defendant below, it follows that our jurisdiction is not shown by the record, and that the suit must be dismissed.

So ordered.


Summaries of

Nagle v. Rutledge

U.S.
Jan 1, 1879
100 U.S. 675 (1879)
Case details for

Nagle v. Rutledge

Case Details

Full title:NAGLE v . RUTLEDGE

Court:U.S.

Date published: Jan 1, 1879

Citations

100 U.S. 675 (1879)

Citing Cases

State v. Plummer

In S. v. French, 109 U.S. 722, it was held that such a tax as that in the present case was not a property…

Smith v. Wilkins

The Confederate soldier is entitled to consideration and recognition at the hands of the General Assembly,…