From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Murphy v. Friel

Appellate Court of Illinois, First District
Apr 24, 1946
328 Ill. App. 586 (Ill. App. Ct. 1946)

Opinion

Gen. No. 43,483. (Abstract of Decision.)

Opinion filed April 24, 1946 Rehearing denied May 10, 1946 Released for publication May 10, 1946

AUTOMOBILES AND MOTOR VEHICLES, § 240when verdict was excessive. In action for damages as result of personal injuries sustained by plaintiff's ward when automobile making "U" turn was hit by defendants' street car and forced against parked automobile which was thrown over curb and inflicted injuries complained of, and it appeared that left leg of ward was fractured in several places and otherwise injured and that jury returned verdict for $75,000, of which $40,000 was remitted, held that verdict was so excessive that it could not be accounted for except on prejudice, passion or misconception of evidence and remittitur did not remove improper elements.

See Callaghan's Illinois Digest, same topic and section number.

Appeal from the Superior Court of Cook county; the Hon. JOHN F. BOLTON, Judge, presiding.

Judgment reversed and cause remanded. Heard in the third division, first district, this court at the October term, 1945.

Frank L. Kriete, James O. Dwight, Charles E. Green, and Arthur J. Donovan, for appellants;

William J. Flaherty and James O. Dwight, of counsel;

James A. Dooley, for appellee.


Not to be published in full. Opinion filed April 24, 1946; rehearing denied May 10, 1946; released for publication May 10, 1946


Summaries of

Murphy v. Friel

Appellate Court of Illinois, First District
Apr 24, 1946
328 Ill. App. 586 (Ill. App. Ct. 1946)
Case details for

Murphy v. Friel

Case Details

Full title:Clare J. Murphy, Conservator of Estate of Max Pashkow, Incompetent…

Court:Appellate Court of Illinois, First District

Date published: Apr 24, 1946

Citations

328 Ill. App. 586 (Ill. App. Ct. 1946)
66 N.E.2d 450

Citing Cases

Stephans v. Chicago Transit Authority

Plaintiff did not suffer any fractures. Where a verdict is so excessive as to show passion and prejudice a…

Pros v. Mid-America Computer Corp.

The reviewing courts have also upheld rulings refusing instructions which would invade the province of the…