From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Munn v. Crow

Supreme Court of South Carolina
Nov 11, 1910
87 S.C. 246 (S.C. 1910)

Opinion

7712

November 11, 1910.

Before GAGE, J., Kershaw, November, 1908. Affirmed.

Action by J.A. Munn against J.H. Crow. From circuit order reversing judgment of Magistrate N.M. Fincher, defendant appeals.

Messrs. M.L. Smith and E.D. Blakeney for appellant.

Mr. B.D. Clarke, contra.


November 11, 1910. The opinion of the Court was delivered by


Plaintiff recovered judgment against defendant in the Circuit Court on appeal from a magistrate's court for $36.80, the balance due for pine timber sold to defendant. There was no dispute about the contract. But defendant contended that, after it was made, he assigned it, with plaintiff's consent, to A.J. Crow and L.D. Jones, who cut the timber and are responsible to plaintiff for it. Plaintiff admitted that he consented to the assignment, but testified that he did not agree to release defendant from liability for the timber cut by his assignees, but distinctly told him that he would look to him for pay. It appears that defendant did make some payments to plaintiff for timber cut after the assignment of the contract, though some were also made by Jones. The defendant says even now that he is responsible to plaintiff for any balance due him by his assignees when they have a settlement with plaintiff.

It appears from the foregoing that there was some testimony to support the findings of fact of the Circuit Court; therefore, they cannot be reviewed in this Court.

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Munn v. Crow

Supreme Court of South Carolina
Nov 11, 1910
87 S.C. 246 (S.C. 1910)
Case details for

Munn v. Crow

Case Details

Full title:MUNN v. CROW

Court:Supreme Court of South Carolina

Date published: Nov 11, 1910

Citations

87 S.C. 246 (S.C. 1910)
69 S.E. 229

Citing Cases

Brown v. Missouri State Life Ins. Co.

"Where a finding by the Circuit Court on appeal from Magistrate [Court] is supported by any evidence, it is…

Kimbrell v. Mills Young Co.

Messrs. Dunlap, Dunlap Hollis, for appellant, cite: Civil Code, sec. 4106. "Mentioned" defined: 5 Words and…