From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

MAXWELL v. HIPP

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jan 1, 1870
64 N.C. 98 (N.C. 1870)

Opinion

January Term, 1870.

A bond for money for the hire of a slave for 1865, given January 2d 1865, is subject to be scaled according to the value of the hire for a year, in lawful money, and not according to the legislative table of the values of Confederate currency (acts of 1865-'66, c. 39.)

DEBT, tried before Logan, J., at January Special Term 1870, of MECKLENBURG Court.

Wilson for the appellant.

No counsel contra.


The plaintiff declared upon a bond of the defendant's for (99) $1010, payable to the plaintiff, and dated January 2d 1865. The plaintiff offered to prove that said bond was given for the hire of a negro man belonging to his intestate, for the year 1865, and that his hire was worth $50.

His Honor excluded the testimony.

Verdict for $7.70, of which $6.21 is principal money, etc., Rule, etc., Judgment, and Appeal by the plaintiff.


The bond declared on was executed during the late war, and there is a legal presumption that it was solvable in Confederate money.

The consideration of this bond was the services of a slave, which belonged to the estate of plaintiff's intestate. The plaintiff ought to have been permitted to introduce evidence as to the value of such consideration, as that was the amount which he was entitled to recover. The legislative scale does not apply to this contract, as the consideration was not Confederate money: Robeson v. Brown, 63 N.C. 554; Garrett v. Smith, ante 93.

There was error in the ruling of his Honor.

Let this be certified.

Per curiam.

Venire de novo.

(100)


Summaries of

MAXWELL v. HIPP

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jan 1, 1870
64 N.C. 98 (N.C. 1870)
Case details for

MAXWELL v. HIPP

Case Details

Full title:T. J. MAXWELL, ADM'R. v. ROBERT HIPP, AND ANOTHER

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Jan 1, 1870

Citations

64 N.C. 98 (N.C. 1870)

Citing Cases

State ex rel. Stocks v. Smith, Adm'r et al

2. If it were admissible to show that the judgment was solvable in Confederate money, then the value of the…

Henry King v. W. W. R. R. Co.

I submit a brief review of the cases upon the subject. Notwithstanding the comprehensive language of the…