From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Marx v. Gross

New York Superior Court — General Term
Feb 1, 1893
2 Misc. 511 (N.Y. Misc. 1893)

Opinion

February, 1893.

James Thomson, for defendants (appellants).

George A. Black, for plaintiffs (respondents).


The action was for damages for the nondelivery of goods agreed by defendants to be delivered to plaintiff.

The learned counsel for the appellants have argued on the appeal certain questions which were not presented on the trial and did not occasion any exception to the rulings of the referee. These were the effect of the Statute of Frauds in the case and whether the principal amount if due, assuming the damages to be unliquidated, bore interest, and also as of what time the damages were to be computed.

I am of opinion that the allegation of the complaint of the contract not being controverted by the answer, was to be taken as true for the purpose of the action. Code Civ. Proc. § 522; Fleischmann v. Stern, 90 N.Y. 110. For the purpose of determining the basis of the cause of action, the allegation of the answer of a contract of other terms or of a different character, has no function or effect.

The differences of fact between the parties have been fully and satisfactorily considered by the learned referee. The facts found by him were supported by evidence. The conclusions of law from the facts were correct.

Judgment affirmed, with costs.

DUGRO and GILDERSLEEVE, JJ., concur.

Judgment affirmed.


Summaries of

Marx v. Gross

New York Superior Court — General Term
Feb 1, 1893
2 Misc. 511 (N.Y. Misc. 1893)
Case details for

Marx v. Gross

Case Details

Full title:MARX v . GROSS

Court:New York Superior Court — General Term

Date published: Feb 1, 1893

Citations

2 Misc. 511 (N.Y. Misc. 1893)
22 N.Y.S. 393

Citing Cases

Vogel Co. v. Reinhardt

Some of the authorities hold that the party who receives the costs by reason of a favor having been granted…

Barnard v. Lawyers' Title Ins. Co.

To be sufficient, therefore, the defense in such a case must not only confess, but also avoid or bar. If it…