From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Martin v. Carroll

Supreme Court of Louisiana
Jan 14, 1952
220 La. 481 (La. 1952)

Opinion

No. 39907.

January 14, 1952.

APPEAL FROM FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT, PARISH OF MOREHOUSE, STATE OF LOUISIANA, HONORABLE EDWARD L. GLADNEY, JR., J.

Madison, Madison, Files Shell, Monroe, W. D. Cotton, Rayville and Paul Sullins, Crossett, Ark., for defendants-appellants.

Charles H. Dameron and J. D. DeBlieux, Baton Rouge, for plaintiffs-appellees.


Plaintiffs instituted this suit to recover an undivided one-half interest in and to a tract of land in Morehouse Parish containing 119.56 acres. The district court rendered a judgment in their favor, as they had prayed, and the defendants are appealing.

From an examination of the record it does not appear that this court has jurisdiction of the appeal. In suits of this nature we are permitted to entertain jurisdiction only where it is clearly shown that the value of the disputed interest in the land exceeds $2000. Section 10, Article 7, Constitution of 1921. No value of the one-half interest contested herein is recited in the pleadings of the parties; and the highest value thereof disclosed by the evidence (computed on a basis of $4 per acre) is $239.12.

True, the record contains a stipulation reading: "It is agreed by counsel for both sides that the value of the property in contest, for jurisdictional purposes, be considered as in excess of $2000."But it is well settled that jurisdiction cannot be vested in this court by consent. Louisiana State Rice Milling Company, Inc., v. Gage, 162 La. 350, 110 So. 555; Reeves v. Barbe, 200 La. 1073, 9 So.2d 426; Tucker v. Woodside, 218 La. 708, 50 So.2d 814.

Therefore, it is ordered that this cause be transferred to the Court of Appeal, Second Circuit, pursuant to the provisions of LSA-R.S. 13:4441, the record to be filed in such court by appellant within 30 days from the date on which this decree shall become final; otherwise the appeal shall stand dismissed.


Summaries of

Martin v. Carroll

Supreme Court of Louisiana
Jan 14, 1952
220 La. 481 (La. 1952)
Case details for

Martin v. Carroll

Case Details

Full title:MARTIN ET AL. v. CARROLL ET AL

Court:Supreme Court of Louisiana

Date published: Jan 14, 1952

Citations

220 La. 481 (La. 1952)
56 So. 2d 843

Citing Cases

Wainer v. Kirn

But the stipulation is without effect, consent of the parties being inappropriate and insufficient for…

Newman v. McClure

It is nevertheless maintained that we are vested with jurisdiction of the case because counsel for the…