From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Macon County v. City of Oglethorpe

Supreme Court of Georgia
Nov 9, 1972
229 Ga. 687 (Ga. 1972)

Opinion

27390.

ARGUED SEPTEMBER 11, 1972.

DECIDED NOVEMBER 9, 1972.

Injunction. Macon Superior Court. Before Judge Marshall.

Blanks Chew, W. F. Blanks, for appellant.

Smith Hargrove, William E. Smith, for appellee.


The City of Oglethorpe sought to enjoin Macon County from constructing a new road through its territory without its consent. Macon County in its answer admitted the construction of the road but averred that said road was not a part of the city's street system, that it would become a functioning part of the State Highway System, and that the action of the city in refusing approval thereof was in bad faith, unreasonable and an abuse of discretion. The trial court granted a motion to strike all defenses except the general denial and enjoined the construction until consented to by the City of Oglethorpe. This appeal followed. Held:

Where a municipal corporation is created, it becomes vested with jurisdiction over the territory within its corporate limits. Counties have no right to construct roads within a municipality without its permission. Almand v. Atlanta Consolidated St. R. Co., 108 Ga. 417 ( 34 S.E. 6); Bd. of Commrs. of Sumter County v. Mayor c. of Americus, 141 Ga. 542 ( 81 S.E. 435); Wood v. Shore, 160 Ga. 173 ( 127 S.E. 145). This rule does not apply to roads being constructed by direction of the State. Lee County v. Mayor c. of Smithville, 154 Ga. 550 ( 115 S.E. 107); State Hwy. Dept. v. MacDonald, 221 Ga. 312 (3b) ( 144 S.E.2d 363). See Code Ann. §§ 95-1504, 95-1738.

The City of Oglethorpe is invested with authority to establish streets within its territory and it was not an act of bad faith, unreasonableness, nor an abuse of discretion to refuse to permit Macon County to encroach upon this prerogative. Macon County's answer that the road "will be a functioning part of the State Highway System" was speculative. It did not show that the road was a part of the State Highway System and was being constructed as a State-aid road at the direction of the State.

These defenses were properly stricken and Macon County having admitted the construction of the road within the city limits without the city's consent, no issues remain to be tried. Therefore, the trial court was authorized to render judgment on the pleadings and the grant of the injunction was not error.

Judgment affirmed. All the Justices concur.

ARGUED SEPTEMBER 11, 1972 — DECIDED NOVEMBER 9, 1972.


Summaries of

Macon County v. City of Oglethorpe

Supreme Court of Georgia
Nov 9, 1972
229 Ga. 687 (Ga. 1972)
Case details for

Macon County v. City of Oglethorpe

Case Details

Full title:MACON COUNTY v. CITY OF OGLETHORPE

Court:Supreme Court of Georgia

Date published: Nov 9, 1972

Citations

229 Ga. 687 (Ga. 1972)
194 S.E.2d 97

Citing Cases

Coweta County v. City of Newnan

Therefore, the county argues that the General Assembly contemplated a contract between the city commission…

City of Coll. Park v. Clayton Cnty.

Likewise, the Georgia Reports include numerous cases in which political subdivisions of the State have been…