From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Mackey v. Railway

Supreme Court of New Hampshire Coos
Dec 3, 1912
85 A. 1134 (N.H. 1912)

Opinion

Decided December 3, 1912.

CASE, for negligence causing the death of Margaret Duggan, the plaintiff's intestate. Trial by jury at the December term, 1911, of the superior court. At the close of the plaintiff's evidence and subject to his exception, the court (Mitchell, J.) withdrew the case from the jury and made certain rulings to which exception was also taken.

Matthew J. Ryan and Herbert I. Goss (Mr. Goss orally), for the plaintiff.

Drew, Shurtleff Morris and Rich Marble (Mr. Marble and Eri C. Oakes orally), for the defendants.


Upon the only ground of liability asserted — the defendants' fault in not avoiding the injury after discovery of the danger — the case cannot be distinguished from Cavanaugh v. Railroad, ante, 68. In view of the suggestion of additional evidence upon the question of damages, there is now no occasion to consider the plaintiff's exception to the ruling thereon, which was not argued. The plaintiff was entitled to go to the jury.

Exception sustained.

All concurred.


Summaries of

Mackey v. Railway

Supreme Court of New Hampshire Coos
Dec 3, 1912
85 A. 1134 (N.H. 1912)
Case details for

Mackey v. Railway

Case Details

Full title:MACKEY, Adm'r, v. GRAND TRUNK RAILWAY CO

Court:Supreme Court of New Hampshire Coos

Date published: Dec 3, 1912

Citations

85 A. 1134 (N.H. 1912)
85 A. 1134

Citing Cases

Le Doux v. Dettmering

(Citing cases.) In Leyden v. Lawrence, 79 N.J. Eq. 113, 81 A. 121, aff'd 80 N.J. Eq. 550, 85 A. 1134, the…