From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Lockwood v. Merchants Despatch Transportation

Supreme Court, Monroe County
Dec 7, 1931
142 Misc. 470 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1931)

Opinion

December 7, 1931.

William L. Clay, for the plaintiff.

Harris, Beach, Folger, Bacon Keating, for the defendant.


The plaintiff is the widow and administratrix of Glenn Lockwood, and is seeking to recover damages for negligence causing the death of the decedent. She is not familiar with the apparatus, machinery and safety devices involved in the work in which the decedent was engaged, or with the conditions under which he worked, and is asking for an examination of officers and employees of defendant to enable her to frame her complaint. There is authority, under the present practice, as there was under the old practice, to have an examination before trial in a proper case, in order to frame a complaint. Such an examination, however, will be permitted only where the plaintiff desires it for the purpose of stating, with sufficient definiteness and certainty, a good complaint. She should have an examination to enable her to state all the grounds of negligence upon which she claims to be entitled to recover.

So ordered.


Summaries of

Lockwood v. Merchants Despatch Transportation

Supreme Court, Monroe County
Dec 7, 1931
142 Misc. 470 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1931)
Case details for

Lockwood v. Merchants Despatch Transportation

Case Details

Full title:MINNIE LOCKWOOD, as Administratrix, etc., Plaintiff, v. THE MERCHANTS…

Court:Supreme Court, Monroe County

Date published: Dec 7, 1931

Citations

142 Misc. 470 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1931)
254 N.Y.S. 573

Citing Cases

MATTER OF WOLLEN v. B.R. DE WITT, INC

And likewise an examination under this section was held proper to ascertain how a child was injured in a…

Matter of Roland

That holding has been the subject of pointed criticism ( Matter of Weiss [ Mount Sinai Hosp.], 208 Misc.…