Lewis v. Bd. of Supervisors of La. State Univ. & Agric. & Mech. Coll.

Full title: SHARON LEWIS, Plaintiff v. BOARD OF SUPERVISORS OF LOUISIANA STATE…

Court: United States District Court, Middle District of Louisiana

Date published: Jul 20, 2023

Civil Action 21-198-SM-RLB (M.D. La. Jul. 20, 2023)

Opinion

Civil Action 21-198-SM-RLB

07-20-2023

SHARON LEWIS, Plaintiff v. BOARD OF SUPERVISORS OF LOUISIANA STATE UNIVERSITY AND AGRICULTURAL AND MECHANICAL COLLEGE, Defendant

SUSIE MORGAN, UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE.

ORDER AND REASONS

SUSIE MORGAN, UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE.

Before the Court is Plaintiff Sharon Lewis's (“Lewis”) Motion to Serve Subpoena for Deposition of Leslie Miles on Peter Ginsberg, Esq., Attorney for Leslie Miles on Behalf of Leslie Miles.¹ The motion is opposed.²

1 R. Doc. 354.

2 R. Doc. 358.

Lewis asks the Court to permit her to serve a Rule 45 subpoena for Leslie Miles on Miles's attorney, Peter Ginsberg.³ Lewis's counsel, Albert Van-Lare, included with the motion a lengthy affidavit detailing his efforts to locate and serve Miles.⁴ Van-Lare declared that he hired an investigator and performed one paid internet search, the latter effort identifying an address where a process server found “an empty house and no for sale sign.”⁵

3 R. Doc. 354.

4 R. Doc. 354-1.

5 Id. at pp. 1-2.

In his opposition, Miles argues that the Fifth Circuit is among those jurisdictions that require personal service of a Rule 45 subpoena,⁶ and even in those jurisdictions that allow alternate service, the party seeking alternate service must first show a “sufficient showing of diligence” toward personal service.⁷

6 R. Doc. 358 at pp. 1-3.

7 Id. at p. 3.

Without ruling on whether the Fifth Circuit permits alternate service of a subpoena under Rule 45, the Court finds that Lewis and her attorney have not made a sufficient showing of diligence to serve Leslie Miles personally.

For example, one recent article in the Miami Herald lists at least six address search services and suggests using public records as an alternate means of locating a person.⁸According to the article, public record resources include “voter registration data and property records.”⁹

8 Ahad Waseem, How to Find Someone's Address With Their Name, MIAMI HERALD (last updated July 1, 2023) https://www.miamiherald.com/software-business/article2724io648.html [https://perma.cc/6Z7W-E2CE].

9 Id.

Van-Lare declared he believes Miles to live in Naples,¹⁰ a city in Collier County, Florida.¹¹ The Collier County Supervisor of Elections maintains a free Voter Information Look-Up website.¹² The Collier County government also allows users to search official land records.¹³ Lewis has not shown that she or her attorneys have availed themselves of these and other publicly available resources. As a result, the Court finds that her efforts thus far have not been sufficiently diligent.

10 R. Doc. 354-1 at p. 2.

11 See COLLIER CO. GOV'T, https://www.colliercountyfl.gov/ [https://perma.cc/53J5-LRAQ] (last visited July 19, 2023).

12 Voter Information Look-Up, COLLIER CO. SUPERVISOR of ELECTIONS, https://www.colliervotes.gov/Voters/Check-My-Registration-Status [https://perma.cc/33LV-FV2D] (last visited July 19, 2023).

13 Search Official/Land Records, CLERK FF CIR. CT. AND COMPTROLLER, COLLIER Co., FLA., https://collierclerk.com/recording-information/search-official-land-records/ [https://perma.cc/GXR7-KGZW] (last visited July 19, 2023).

Accordingly;

IT IS ORDERED that Lewis's motion is DENIED without prejudice. Lewis may conduct additional efforts to locate and serve Leslie Miles and refile her motion on or before Friday, August 11, 2023.