Opinion
Index No. 950398/20 No. 224 Case No. 2021-04273
05-09-2023
J.A.F., Plaintiff-Appellant, v. The Roman Catholic Archdiocese of New York, Defendant-Respondent Marist Brothers of the Schools, Inc. Doing Business as The Marist Brothers Province of the United States of America et al., Defendants.
Levy Konigsberg LLP, New York (Matthew Shock of counsel), for appellant. Leahey & Johnson, P.C., New York (Peter James Johnson of counsel), for respondent.
Levy Konigsberg LLP, New York (Matthew Shock of counsel), for appellant.
Leahey & Johnson, P.C., New York (Peter James Johnson of counsel), for respondent.
Before: Webber, J.P., Kern, Friedman, Mendez, Shulman, JJ.
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (George J. Silver, J.), entered October 5, 2021, which granted so much of the motion of defendant The Roman Catholic Archdiocese of New York (the Archdiocese) to dismiss the complaint pursuant to CPLR 3211(a)(1), unanimously reversed, on the law, without costs, and the motion denied.
In consonance with this Court's decision in J.D. v Archdiocese of N.Y., 214A.D.3d 216 [1st Dept 2023]), we determine that the documentary evidence submitted by the Archdiocese in support of its CPLR 3211(a)(1) motion to dismiss the complaint against it failed to "utterly refute" the allegations in the complaint that plaintiff's abusers, Marist Brother Timothy Brady and Father Bernard J. Lynch, were agents of the Archdiocese, that the Archdiocese exercised supervision and control over their appointment or employ, and that a special relationship existed between plaintiff, the Archdiocese, and the other defendants (see id.; see generally Goshen v Mutual Life Ins. Co. of N.Y., 98 N.Y.2d 314, 326-327 [2002]). For instance, the deed only indicated that the Archdiocese did not legally own the premises where the alleged abuse occurred. The deed did not foreclose the possibility that the alleged abusers were agents of the Archdiocese, or that the Archdiocese had supervisory authority over them. Accordingly, the Archdiocese failed to conclusively establish a defense as a matter of law.