From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Jacobson v. Shober

United States District Court, E. D. Pennsylvania
Jan 7, 1948
7 F.R.D. 653 (E.D. Pa. 1948)

Opinion

         Action by Oscar Jacobson, Anna Jacobson and Harry Towne against Margaret H. Shober, to recover damages arising out of an automobile collision wherein defendant filed a motion to sever the cause of action of Oscar Jacobson from that of Anna Jacobson and Harry Towne so that Oscar Jacobson could be joined as an additional defendant to the actions of Anna Jacobson and Harry Towne.

         Order of severance granted.

          Edward Marcu, of Philadelphia, Pa., for plaintiff.

          Michael A. Foley, of Philadelphia, Pa., for defendant.


          BARD, District Judge.

         Oscar Jacobson and Anna Jacobson, his wife, and Harry Towne are joined as plaintiffs in this case, which arises out of a collision between an automobile driven by Oscar Jacobson and the defendant's automobile. Anna Jacobson, the wife, and Harry Towne were passengers in the automobile operated by Oscar Jacobson at the time of the collision.

         The defendant has moved to sever the cause of action of Oscar Jacobson from that of Anna Jacobson and Harry Towne, so that Oscar Jacobson may be joined as an additional defendant to the actions of Anna Jacobson and Harry Towne. The defendant contends that Oscar Jacobson was either solely responsible or jointly responsible for the accident, and, in the latter event, she wishes to protect her right to contribution from Oscar Jacobson by joining him as an additional defendant.

         I am of the opinion that the defendant's contention must be sustained and that her motion for severance must be granted. See opinion by President Judge Keller in Fisher v. Diehl, 156 Pa.Super. 476, 40 A.2d 912, and cases there cited.

         An order may be entered severing the cause of action of Oscar Jacobson from that of Anna Jacobson and Harry Towne.


Summaries of

Jacobson v. Shober

United States District Court, E. D. Pennsylvania
Jan 7, 1948
7 F.R.D. 653 (E.D. Pa. 1948)
Case details for

Jacobson v. Shober

Case Details

Full title:JACOBSON et al. v. SHOBER.

Court:United States District Court, E. D. Pennsylvania

Date published: Jan 7, 1948

Citations

7 F.R.D. 653 (E.D. Pa. 1948)

Citing Cases

Weisler v. Matta

As to No. 8764, defendants moved to sever the claim of Louise from that of administrator Weisler and that of…

McMichael v. Delaware Coach Co.

It has been done under similar circumstances by the Federal Courts. Sporia v. Pennsylvania Greyhound Lines, 3…