From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Jacobs v. Willie

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Jul 13, 1915
150 P. 709 (Okla. 1915)

Opinion

No. 5873

Opinion Filed July 13, 1915.

1. APPEAL AND ERROR — Presentation for Review — Errors Occurring on Trial. Errors alleged to have occurred on the trial of a cause cannot be presented to this court in the absence of a bill of exceptions or case-made.

2. SAME. The rulings of the trial court on the admission or rejection of evidence, the giving or refusal of instructions, the overruling of a motion for a new trial, and the exceptions taken, are not a part of the record proper, and can be presented for review on appeal only by incorporating the same into a bill of exceptions or case-made.

(Syllabus by the Court.)

Error from Superior Court, Oklahoma County; Edward Dewes Oldfield, Judge.

Action by Louie Jacobs against Bessie Willie. Judgment for defendant, and plaintiff brings error. Dismissed.

Shirk Danner, for plaintiff in error.

Giddings Giddings, for defendant in error.


The appeal in this case is by transcript of the record. A motion to dismiss the appeal has been filed, to which plaintiff in error has made no answer. All of the alleged errors contained in the petition in error occurred at and during the trial, and cannot, therefore, be presented for the consideration of this court by transcript, but must be brought to its attention, if at all, by means of a case-made or bill of exceptions. Simpson v. Henderson-Sturges Piano Co., 31 Okla. 623, 122 P. 174; Stonebraker-Zea Cattle Co. v. Hilton, 34 Okla. 225, 124 P. 1062; Laborn et al. v. Stephens et al., ante, 147 P. 152.

The appeal is, accordingly, dismissed.

All the Justices concur.


Summaries of

Jacobs v. Willie

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Jul 13, 1915
150 P. 709 (Okla. 1915)
Case details for

Jacobs v. Willie

Case Details

Full title:JACOBS v. WILLIE

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Jul 13, 1915

Citations

150 P. 709 (Okla. 1915)
150 P. 709

Citing Cases

Lawton Grain Co. v. Brunswig

Defendant in error filed motion to dismiss this proceeding for the reason that errors assigned do not appear…

In re Combs' Estate

Motions, including those for new trial, are not a part of the record proper. Tribal Dev. Co. v. White Bros.,…