From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

J. S. McCall Sons v. Roemer

Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, San Antonio
May 17, 1916
186 S.W. 409 (Tex. Civ. App. 1916)

Opinion

No. 5678.

May 17, 1916.

Appeal from Bastrop County Court; J. B. Price, Judge.

Action by J. S. McCall Sons against E. Roemer and another. From a judgment in favor of the named defendant, plaintiffs appeal. Affirmed.

Wade Felts, of Elgin, and Page Jones, of Bastrop, for appellants. Orgain Maynard and P. C. Maynard, all of Bastrop, for appellee.


J. S. McCall Sons sued E. Roemer and L. V. Bigham on an account for goods, wares, and merchandise alleged to have been sold to said Bigham at the instance and request of Roemer and upon the credit of the latter and in order to enable Bigham to make a crop on Roemer's farm during the year 1914. Bigham, in open court, admitted the justness of the account. Roemer, in addition to a general denial, specially denied that he requested plaintiffs to sell Bigham any goods or that he promised to pay the account, and, in addition, plead the statute of frauds. The jury, pursuant to the peremptory instruction of the court, returned a verdict in favor of defendant Roemer and against Bigham. Judgment was entered in accordance with the verdict, and plaintiffs appealed.

All of the assignments of error are directed at the ruling of the court in giving the peremptory instruction to return a verdict in favor of Roemer. It does not appear from the record that plaintiffs interposed any objections to the giving of such instruction. No exception was taken to the ruling until the motion for new trial was presented. This court has recently held that the statute requiring objections to be made to the charge, and exceptions to be saved to the ruling thereon, applies to a peremptory Instruction. Strong v. Harwell, 185 S.W. 676, not yet officially reported.

As appellants are not in a position entitling them to complain of the charge, the assignment must be overruled.

Judgment affirmed.


Summaries of

J. S. McCall Sons v. Roemer

Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, San Antonio
May 17, 1916
186 S.W. 409 (Tex. Civ. App. 1916)
Case details for

J. S. McCall Sons v. Roemer

Case Details

Full title:J. S. McCALL SONS v. ROEMER

Court:Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, San Antonio

Date published: May 17, 1916

Citations

186 S.W. 409 (Tex. Civ. App. 1916)

Citing Cases

Yate's Mercantile Co. v. Farmers' Guaranty State Bank of Jacksonville

The assignments of error present different reasons why that instruction should not have been given. The…

Toole v. Moore

ction in giving a peremptory instruction, timely and proper objection must be made thereto before such charge…