From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

In re Brodbeck

Supreme Court of New Jersey
Mar 17, 1958
139 A.2d 569 (N.J. 1958)

Opinion

Argued February 17, 1958 —

Decided March 17, 1958.

Mr. Charles A. Cohen argued the cause for appellants ( Mr. Thomas F. McGuire, attorney).

Mr. William S. Keown argued the cause for respondent ( Mr. Walter S. Keown, attorney).


The interrogatories should have been answered, and there was little justification for the extended failure to do so. Dismissal of the cause, however, was too drastic a penalty. Counsel's default is not to be condoned, but under the circumstances here presented it should not have deprived his clients of their day in court.

The judgment is reversed and the cause is remanded for further proceedings. No costs to either party.

For reversal — Chief Justice WEINTRAUB, and Justices HEHER, WACHENFELD, BURLING, JACOBS, FRANCIS and PROCTOR — 7.

For affirmance — None.


Summaries of

In re Brodbeck

Supreme Court of New Jersey
Mar 17, 1958
139 A.2d 569 (N.J. 1958)
Case details for

In re Brodbeck

Case Details

Full title:IN THE MATTER OF THE PROBATE OF THE ALLEGED WILL OF WILLIAM J. BRODBECK…

Court:Supreme Court of New Jersey

Date published: Mar 17, 1958

Citations

139 A.2d 569 (N.J. 1958)
139 A.2d 569