From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

In re Application for Disbarment of Knott

Supreme Court of California
Jan 24, 1887
71 Cal. 584 (Cal. 1887)

Opinion

         Application for the disbarment of an attorney and counselor at law.

         COUNSEL

          Page & Eells, for Complainant.

          Roger Johnson, for Respondent.


         JUDGES: In Bank.

         OPINION

         THE COURT          This is a proceeding to disbar the respondent for making what is claimed to have been a false affidavit in a proceeding to obtain a patent at Washington.

         Apparently the affidavit was one which the respondent may have believed to have been literally and technically true, but which was morally false, and was, in effect, an imposition upon the secretary, with whom it was filed.

         We have before had occasion to condemn the practice which is too common, of making affidavits to what the affiant may claim to be the legal effect of facts not stated. They are often simply impositions upon the court. In this case the respondent was at the time young and inexperienced, and relied upon the assura nce of an older and more experienced lawyer, [12 P. 781] that he could properly make the affidavit.

         It was not really an act as an attorney in our jurisdiction, and could probably only be considered as affecting the moral character of the respondent. The accuser desires to have the proceeding dismissed, saying that he made the accusation under the influence of anger. We do not recognize the right of an accuser to have such a proceeding dismissed; but having examined the evidence, we are inclined, in view of all the circumstances, to attribute the fault, though a grave one, to youth, inexperience, and ignorance.

         The proceeding is therefore dismissed.


Summaries of

In re Application for Disbarment of Knott

Supreme Court of California
Jan 24, 1887
71 Cal. 584 (Cal. 1887)
Case details for

In re Application for Disbarment of Knott

Case Details

Full title:In the Matter of the Application for the Disbarment of W. W. KNOTT

Court:Supreme Court of California

Date published: Jan 24, 1887

Citations

71 Cal. 584 (Cal. 1887)
12 P. 780

Citing Cases

Nicholson v. Tarpey

3. At the trial, plaintiff, as a witness in his own behalf, testified that after he moved to the land bought…