From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

In re the Tax Appeal of Island Holidays, Ltd.

Supreme Court of Hawaii
Aug 15, 1978
582 P.2d 703 (Haw. 1978)

Opinion

NO. 5961

August 15, 1978

PETITION FOR REHEARING

C. Michael Hare and Richard L. Griffith (Cades Schutte Fleming Wright of counsel) for Taxpayer, Appellant, for the petition.

RICHARDSON, C.J., KOBAYASHI, OGATA, MENOR AND KIDWELL, JJ.


Appellant has petitioned for rehearing in this case upon the sole ground that the decision of this court was upon a question which had not been briefed or argued. The petition does not set forth any points or authorities relied upon to establish that the decision was erroneous.

The contention of appellant in this appeal has been that the distribution of previously taxed income by a joint venture to its members is not subject to general excise taxation. The appellee has contended that the payments to appellant were for services rendered to the joint venture and were therefore subject to tax, relying by analogy upon the treatment of such income for net income tax purposes. While rejecting the reasoning of appellee, this court has upheld the contention of appellee that payments to a joint venturer for services may be subject to general excise taxation notwithstanding that such payments constitute a distribution of joint venture income. The decision turned upon a point which had been briefed and argued, although this court relied upon a statute to which the parties had not directed attention.

No ground for rehearing having been presented, the petition for rehearing is denied.


Summaries of

In re the Tax Appeal of Island Holidays, Ltd.

Supreme Court of Hawaii
Aug 15, 1978
582 P.2d 703 (Haw. 1978)
Case details for

In re the Tax Appeal of Island Holidays, Ltd.

Case Details

Full title:IN THE MATTER OF THE TAX APPEAL OF ISLAND HOLIDAYS, LTD., TAXPAYER

Court:Supreme Court of Hawaii

Date published: Aug 15, 1978

Citations

582 P.2d 703 (Haw. 1978)
582 P.2d 703

Citing Cases

In re the Tax Appeal of Brewer & Co.

"In enacting . . . [the general excise tax], the legislature cast a wide and tight net." In re Tax Appeal of…

In re Queen's Medical Center

"In enacting [HRS] Chapter 237, the legislature [undoubtedly] cast a wide and tight net." In re Tax Appeal of…