From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Hazen v. Hazen

Supreme Court of Rhode Island
Oct 18, 1973
310 A.2d 143 (R.I. 1973)

Opinion

October 18, 1973.

PRESENT: Roberts, C.J., Paolino, Joslin and Kelleher, JJ.

CERTIORARI. Scope of Review. In certiorari proceedings Supreme Court does not weigh evidence but merely examines the record to determine if there is any competent evidence which will support findings below.

CERTIORARI petition to review Family Court support order, heard and petition denied and dismissed, writ quashed and papers returned to Family Court with decision endorsed thereon.

Kirshenbaum Kirshenbaum, Alfred Factor, for plaintiff-respondent.

Marvin A. Brill, for defendant-petitioner.


We have issued certiorari to review a support order entered by a justice of the Family Court on July 13, 1972. Our action was prompted by the petitioner's assertion that the total amount of the support order exceeds his weekly net take-home pay. The petitioner is an officer and an employee of a family corporation which owns and operates a motel located in East Providence.

In certiorari proceedings we do not weigh the evidence but merely examine the record to determine if there is any competent evidence which will support the court's findings. The petitioner testified that his net take-home weekly pay was $128.05. His wife, however, when asked how much money her husband earned each week, replied "over $300 a week." The trial justice specifically found that petitioner's testimony as it related to the amount of weekly income was unbelievable. This finding will not be disturbed.

The petition for certiorari is denied and dismissed. The writ previously issued is quashed and the papers certified to us are returned to the Family Court with our decision endorsed thereon.

Mr. Justice Doris did not participate.


Summaries of

Hazen v. Hazen

Supreme Court of Rhode Island
Oct 18, 1973
310 A.2d 143 (R.I. 1973)
Case details for

Hazen v. Hazen

Case Details

Full title:SANDRA M. HAZEN vs. IRWIN M. HAZEN

Court:Supreme Court of Rhode Island

Date published: Oct 18, 1973

Citations

310 A.2d 143 (R.I. 1973)
310 A.2d 143

Citing Cases

Narragansett v. Int'l Assoc. Fire Fighters

[1, 2] On review by writ of certiorari, this court does not weigh the evidence before the lower tribunal, but…

Hazen v. Hazen

On respondent's request we issued certiorari to review the support order entered by the Family Court, but,…