From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Estate of Scott

Supreme Court of California
Jan 1, 1860
15 Cal. 220 (Cal. 1860)

Opinion

         Application for mandamus to the Probate Judge of city and county of San Francisco.

         Charles G. Scott died out of this State, leaving property in Santa Clara county, where letters of administration were granted to K., a creditor. Subsequently, the widow of S. arrives in California and applies to the Probate Court of Santa Clara to revoke the letters of K., on the ground that they should have been granted by the Probate Court of San Francisco. The attorneys of the widow and of K. then filed a stipulation, agreeing that the cause be transferred to the Probate Court of San Francisco; K. also filing a petition, as administrator, that the cause be so transferred, on the ground that the widow and a majority of the witnesses resided there, that a portion of the estate of the deceased was there, and that the interests of several persons interested in the estate would be advanced by the transfer. The Santa Clara Court ordered the cause to be transferred. The papers having been filed in the Probate Court of San Francisco, K. applied to that Court for leave to sell the real estate of his intestate. The Court declined taking jurisdiction of the cause, and made an order transferring it to the Probate Court of Santa Clara. K. then applied to this latter Court for a like order of sale, but the Court decided it had lost jurisdiction of the cause by the transfer to San Francisco, and declined any order.

         The administrator applies to the Supreme Court for a mandamus compelling the Probate Judge of San Francisco to take jurisdiction of the cause.

         COUNSEL

          R. F. Ryan, for the Writ.


         JUDGES: Baldwin, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. Cope, J., concurring.

         OPINION

         BALDWIN, Judge.

         The petition for a mandamus is denied. The Probate Court of Santa Clara had jurisdiction, of which it could not divest itself, and vest the jurisdiction in the Probate Court of San Francisco county, upon the facts in the record.

         These proceedings for the settlement of an estate, and matters connected therewith, are not civil actions within the meaning of the Practice Act, secs. 18 to 21. The Judge of the Probate Court of San Francisco county was right in remanding the cause to the Probate Court of Santa Clara; who will proceed to act in the premises as if no order for the removal of the papers and the matter had been made.


Summaries of

Estate of Scott

Supreme Court of California
Jan 1, 1860
15 Cal. 220 (Cal. 1860)
Case details for

Estate of Scott

Case Details

Full title:ESTATE OF CHARLES G. SCOTT

Court:Supreme Court of California

Date published: Jan 1, 1860

Citations

15 Cal. 220 (Cal. 1860)

Citing Cases

In re Estate of Joseph

It was held in an early case that "proceedings for the settlement of an estate and matters connected…

Estate of Davis

The jurisdiction was exclusive in Tulare County where respondent first filed his petition. (Code Civ. Proc.,…