From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Duffy v. Saif

Oregon Court of Appeals
Dec 10, 1979
603 P.2d 1191 (Or. Ct. App. 1979)

Opinion

No. WCB 77-18, CA 12147

Argued and submitted February 27, 1979

Reversed December 10, 1979

Judicial Review from Workers' Compensation Board.

Sharon C. Stevens, Albany, argued the cause for petitioner. On the brief were J. David Kryger, and Emmons, Kyle, Kropp Kryger, Albany.

Lawrence J. Hall, Associate Counsel, State Accident Insurance Fund, Salem, argued the cause for respondent — cross-petitioner. With him on the brief were K. R. Maloney, Chief Counsel, and James A. Blevins, Chief Trial Counsel, State Accident Insurance Fund, Salem.

Before Schwab, Chief Judge, and Buttler and Joseph, Judges.


SCHWAB, C. J.

Reversed.


Claimant had suffered from coronary artery disease of long standing. The mental and physical stress of his employment, superimposed upon his underlying heart ailment, caused attacks of angina pectoris to the extent that he was required to stop work. The State Accident Insurance Fund accepted the claim for the purpose of treatment of the angina pectoris, but denied responsibility for the underlying heart condition. The referee entered an order, with which the Board agreed, affirming the Fund's denial of the responsibility of the underlying heart disease, but making a permanent partial disability award for the angina condition. Claimant contends he is entitled to a larger permanent disability award; the Fund contends that he suffered no permanent disability arising out of his employment. We agree with the Fund.

The Fund does not say that it should not have accepted responsibility for the angina attacks, but see Weller v. Union Carbide, 288 Or. 27, 602 P.2d 259 (1979); Gibson v. SAIF, 288 Or. 45, 602 P.2d 266 (1979).

We are satisfied from the medical evidence that all that happened to claimant as a result of his work were temporary episodes of angina pectoris which stopped when he quit his work and did not affect in any way the severity or progress of his underlying heart disease.

Reversed.


]EDITORS' NOTE: THIS PAGE IS BLANK.]


Summaries of

Duffy v. Saif

Oregon Court of Appeals
Dec 10, 1979
603 P.2d 1191 (Or. Ct. App. 1979)
Case details for

Duffy v. Saif

Case Details

Full title:DUFFY, Petitioner, v. STATE ACCIDENT INSURANCE FUND, Respondent …

Court:Oregon Court of Appeals

Date published: Dec 10, 1979

Citations

603 P.2d 1191 (Or. Ct. App. 1979)
603 P.2d 1191

Citing Cases

Nashville Livestock Commission v. Cox

While there are dicta in Black (and mentioned in Kempner's) that indicate angina pectoris is not compensable,…

Cox v. Nashville Livestock Commission

Clearly it was not necessary to our decision in Black to answer that question or establish such a sweeping…