From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

COX v. JONES

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Sep 1, 1893
18 S.E. 199 (N.C. 1893)

Opinion

September Term, 1893

Appeal — Defective Record — Laches in Perfecting Record.

Where a case was remanded from this Court at Spring Term, 1892, to the end that appellant might have a lost record supplied by proper proceedings in the court below, which has not been done, and the record is as defective as when the order of remand was made, though three or four terms of the Superior Court in that county have transpired and no excuse is rendered for the laches, the case will be dismissed on motion of appellee under rule 15 of the Supreme court.

Devereux Batchelor for plaintiff.

H. R. Kornegay for defendants. (277)


This was a motion made in September, 1888, to set aside a judgment rendered in a special proceeding in 1871. The appeal was docketed here at Fall Term, 1891. The record of the special proceeding not being sent up, a certiorari was sent down to which the clerk returned that after diligent search, only fragmentary parts thereof could be found, and these he sent up. Thereupon, at Spring Term, 1892, the case was remanded ( 110 N.C. 309), to the end that the appellant might take steps to have the lost record supplied by proper proceedings in the court below. This he has not done, and the Court is unable to pass upon the case as presented in the voluminous, irregular and insufficient transcript. The record is as defective as when the order of the remand was made, though since then there have been three or four terms of the Superior Court in that County. No excuse is rendered which atones for this laches. The cause having been here two terms since (Fall Term, 1892, and Spring Term, 1893), the motion of appellee to dismiss the appeal under rule 15 is allowed. Brantly v. Jordan, 92 N.C. 291; Wiseman v. Commissioners, 104 N.C. 330.

Appeal dismissed.


Summaries of

COX v. JONES

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Sep 1, 1893
18 S.E. 199 (N.C. 1893)
Case details for

COX v. JONES

Case Details

Full title:W. A. COX, ADMINISTRATOR, v. NANCY A. JONES ET AL

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Sep 1, 1893

Citations

18 S.E. 199 (N.C. 1893)
113 N.C. 276