From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Camden Gas Corporation v. Camden

Supreme Court of Arkansas
Apr 6, 1931
37 S.W.2d 74 (Ark. 1931)

Opinion

Opinion delivered April 6, 1931.

1. APPEAL AND ERROR — TIME FOR PERFECTING RECORD. — It is the established rule of the Supreme Court, where it has acquired jurisdiction of a case on appeal by the filing of a certified copy of the judgment or decree within the time prescribed by statute, to allow appellant to perfect the record within a reasonable time. 2. APPEAL AND ERROR — TIME FOR APPEALING. — The statutory time for taking an appeal from a judgment or decree is jurisdictional. 3. APPEAL — TRANSCRIPT. — The transcript on an appeal is nothing but a certified copy of the record in the court below. 4. APPEAL AND ERROR — AMENDING TRANSCRIPT. — Where a certified copy of a judgment or decree appealed from has been filed within time, the rule that omitted portions of the record may be supplied within a reasonable time thereafter is not changed by Acts 1923, No. 327, 2, requiring the transcript on appeal in certain cases to be lodged in the Supreme Court within 60 days after final judgment.

Appeal from Ouachita Circuit Court, Second Division; W. A. Speer, Judge; motion to dismiss denied.

Robinson, House Moses, for appellant.

Haynie, Parks Westfall and Gaughan, Sifford, Godwin Gaughan, for appellee.


It has always been the practice of this court to permit the parties, at any time before final decision, to supply omitted portions of the record which have not been brought up on appeal and which are essential to the correct decision of the case. It has also become the established rule of the court, where it has acquired jurisdiction of the case on appeal by the filing of a certified copy of the judgment or decree in the case within the time prescribed by statute, to allow appellant to perfect the record within a reasonable time.

We do not think that 2 of act 327 of the Acts of 1923, providing that an appeal may be taken from the decision of the circuit court in cases like this, but that the transcript must be lodged with the clerk of the Supreme Court within sixty days from the date of final judgment, has the effect to change the rule heretofore adopted. The court has uniformly held that the statutory time for appealing is jurisdictional. Sample v. Manning, 168 Ark. 122, 269 S.W. 55, and cases cited; Caudle v. Turner, 179 Ark. 337, 15 S.W.2d 978; and Bank of El Paso v. Neal, 181 Ark. 788, 27 S.W.2d 1024.

The transcript is nothing but a certified copy of the record in the court below, and we still adhere to our established rule that an imperfect record may be supplied after the expiration of the statutory period where it is done within a reasonable time. Bell v. Rice, ante p. 105. The statute under consideration does not provide that a perfect transcript or record must be lodged with the clerk of this court within 60 days.

When we consider the size of the record, together with the time asked to perfect the record and the other circumstances surrounding the appeal, as shown by the orders heretofore made by the court, we do not think an unreasonable time has been taken in perfecting the transcript; and the motion to dismiss the appeal or affirm the judgment on that account will be overruled.


Summaries of

Camden Gas Corporation v. Camden

Supreme Court of Arkansas
Apr 6, 1931
37 S.W.2d 74 (Ark. 1931)
Case details for

Camden Gas Corporation v. Camden

Case Details

Full title:CAMDEN GAS CORPORATION v. CAMDEN

Court:Supreme Court of Arkansas

Date published: Apr 6, 1931

Citations

37 S.W.2d 74 (Ark. 1931)
37 S.W.2d 74

Citing Cases

Searcy County v. Holder

"Appeals shall be granted as a matter of right to the circuit court from all final orders and judgments of…

O'Daniel v. the Brunswick Balke Collender Company

But if the appeal is not perfected by either party within the limitation provided in 2746, then this court is…