From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Burns v. Toney

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Jan 10, 1911
117 P. 209 (Okla. 1911)

Opinion

No. 638

Opinion Filed January 10, 1911.

APPEAL AND ERROR — Defect of Parties — Dismissal. All persons against whom a joint judgment has been rendered must be made parties to a proceeding to reverse such judgment, and a failure to join any of them, either as plaintiffs or defendants, is ground for the dismissal of the case.

(Syllabus by the Court.)

Error from District Court, Stephens County; Frank M. Bailey, Judge.

Action between L. E. Toney and Robert Burns, receiver, and others. From a judgment for plaintiff, Robert Burns brings error. Dismissed.

Robert Burns, pro se.

Gilbert Bond and J. B. Wilkinson, for defendant in error.


The appeal in this case must be dismissed. The judgment rendered below seems to have been a joint judgment against the Bank of Comanche, the Comanche National Bank of Comanche, and other parties. Robert Burns, receiver of the Bank of Comanche, alone appeals. In Vaught v. Miners' Bank of Joplin, ante, 111 P. 214, this court held that:

"All persons against whom a joint judgment has been rendered must be made parties to a proceeding to reverse such judgment, and a failure to join any of them, either as plaintiffs or defendants, is ground for the dismissal of the case."

The appeal is dismissed.

All the Justices concur.


Summaries of

Burns v. Toney

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Jan 10, 1911
117 P. 209 (Okla. 1911)
Case details for

Burns v. Toney

Case Details

Full title:BURNS, Receiver, v. TONEY

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Jan 10, 1911

Citations

117 P. 209 (Okla. 1911)
117 P. 209

Citing Cases

Tupelo Townsite Co. v. Cook

"All persons against whom a joint judgment has been rendered must be made parties to a proceeding to reverse…

Moser et al. v. Board of Trustees of Town of Thomas

It has become the well-settled law of this state that all parties against whom a joint judgment has been…