From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

BUIE v. SIMMONS

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Feb 1, 1884
90 N.C. 9 (N.C. 1884)

Opinion

(February Term, 1884.)

Appeal — Defective Record.

Where an appeal is taken and the record fails to disclose the grounds upon which the party seeks relief (here against an execution), the court will remand the case, that the record may be perfected.

( Bradley v. Jones, 76 N.C. 204, cited and approved).

MOTION to set aside an execution heard at Spring Term, 1883, of CUMBERLAND Superior Court, before Shipp, J.

Messrs. N.W. Ray and W. A. Guthrie, for plaintiff.

Messrs. R. S. Huske and J. W. Hinsdale, for defendant.


The motion was refused and the defendant appealed.


The record in this case is very imperfect, so much so that we are unable to decide the questions intended to be presented by it, until it shall be perfected.

The names of the persons asking to be made parties as the widow and heirs at law, the grounds and scope of the motion to set aside the execution, which they proposed to make, do not sufficiently appear. The summary statement of the case upon appeal shows that there may have been sufficient grounds for the motion. We are not prepared to say that the appellants are not entitled, in any view of the matter, to make the motion they asked the court to be allowed to make.

In such a case, with a view to the ends of justice, the court will remand the case, to the end that the record may be perfected. Bradley v. Jones, 76 N.C. 204.

Remanded.


Summaries of

BUIE v. SIMMONS

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Feb 1, 1884
90 N.C. 9 (N.C. 1884)
Case details for

BUIE v. SIMMONS

Case Details

Full title:JOHN BUIE v. GEORGE D. SIMMONS

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Feb 1, 1884

Citations

90 N.C. 9 (N.C. 1884)

Citing Cases

Spence Ross v. Tapscott

Where the transcript of the record sent to the Supreme Court is imperfect, the appeal will not be dismissed,…

BUIE v. SCOTT

This, necessarily, was testimony as to a personal transaction between the plaintiff and the deceased, and…