From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Brendle v. Reese

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Sep 1, 1894
20 S.E. 721 (N.C. 1894)

Opinion

(September Term, 1894.)

Practice — Case on Appeal — Motion to Remand — Appeal from an Interlocutory Order — Amendment.

1. Where there is no case on appeal and the appellant has been in no laches, a motion to remand would be allowed if a case on appeal were essential.

2. An appeal does not lie from an interlocutory order before final judgment.

3. The granting or refusing an amendment is a matter of discretion, and no appeal lies therefrom.

MOTION to remand the cause, on the ground that there is no case on appeal.

G.S. Ferguson and J. B. Batchelor for appellant.

No counsel contra.


The appellant moves to remand the cause because there is no case on appeal, and the judge ( Graves) died before settling the same. This would be true, if it was an appeal in which a case settled is essential, and the appellant has not been guilty of laches. State v. Parks, 107 N.C. 821. But the present case is an appeal from a refusal of leave to amend the answer. No case on appeal was necessary, as there were no facts dehors the record to be set out. Furthermore, no appeal lay at this stage, as it was an interlocutory order, nor indeed, at all, as the granting or refusal of the amendment was a matter of discretion. Henry v. Cannon, 86 N.C. 24, and numerous other cases cited in Clark's Code (2 Ed.), pp. 564, 565.

Appeal dismissed.

Cited: Heath v. Lancaster, 116 N.C. 70; Faison v. Williams, 121 N.C. 153.

(553)


Summaries of

Brendle v. Reese

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Sep 1, 1894
20 S.E. 721 (N.C. 1894)
Case details for

Brendle v. Reese

Case Details

Full title:J. M. BRENDLE v. A. J. REESE ET AL

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Sep 1, 1894

Citations

20 S.E. 721 (N.C. 1894)
115 N.C. 552

Citing Cases

State v. Parks

Clemmons v. Archbell, ante, 653, and the cases there cited. New trial. Cited: Ritter v. Grimm, 114 N.C. 374;…

Henry v. Cannon

No error. Affirmed. Cited: Long v. Logan, 86 N.C. 537; Wiggins v. McCoy, 87 N.C. 500; Brooks v. Brooks, 90…