From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Beatty v. Myrick

Supreme Court of Georgia
Feb 7, 1963
218 Ga. 629 (Ga. 1963)

Opinion

21929.

ARGUED JANUARY 15, 1963.

DECIDED FEBRUARY 7, 1963.

Equitable petition. Chatham Superior Court. Before Judge Harrison.

James W. Head, John F. M. Ranitz, Jr., John B. Miller, Reginald Haupt, James W. Dorsey, for plaintiffs in error.

Connerat, Dunn, Hunter, Houlihan Maclean, Stanley W. Feiler, Malcolm Maclean, Corish, Smith Remler, Malberry Smith, Bouhan, Lawrence, Williams, Levy McAlpin, Sol Clark, Kirk McAlpin, Erwin A. Freidman, John W. Sognier, John R. Calhoun, Brannen, Clark Hester, Friedman Weiner, contra.


This is an equitable action in which the plaintiffs seek to have adjudicated which of two named candidates was legally elected to represent the Third Senatorial District in the State Senate. Art. III, Sec. VII, Par. I of the Constitution of Georgia ( Code Ann. § 2-1901) provides: "Each House shall be the judge of the election, returns, and qualifications of its members and shall have power to punish them for disorderly behavior, or misconduct, by censure, fine, imprisonment, or expulsion; but no member shall be expelled, except by a vote of two-thirds of the House to which he belongs." The State Senate being vested by the Constitution with exclusive power to adjudge the qualifications of its own members, the trial court had no jurisdiction to entertain the case and properly sustained the general demurrers to the petition. Rainey v. Taylor, 166 Ga. 476 ( 143 S.E. 383).

Judgment affirmed. All the Justices concur.

ARGUED JANUARY 15, 1963 — DECIDED FEBRUARY 7, 1963.


Summaries of

Beatty v. Myrick

Supreme Court of Georgia
Feb 7, 1963
218 Ga. 629 (Ga. 1963)
Case details for

Beatty v. Myrick

Case Details

Full title:BEATTY et al. v. MYRICK, Ordinary, et al

Court:Supreme Court of Georgia

Date published: Feb 7, 1963

Citations

218 Ga. 629 (Ga. 1963)
129 S.E.2d 764

Citing Cases

Bond v. Floyd

The Senate or House, as happened to be the case, was deemed to have exclusive jurisdiction under the Georgia…

Beatty v. Myrick

The trial judge sustained general demurrers to the petition and dismissed it. There was no supersedeas and…