From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Alexander Dawson, Inc. v. Hydroponics, Inc.

Supreme Court of Utah
May 28, 1975
535 P.2d 1251 (Utah 1975)

Opinion

No. 13909.

May 28, 1975.

Appeal from the Fifth District Court, Washington County, J. Harlan Burns, J.

Phillip L. Foremaster, St. George, for plaintiff and appellant.

Frank A. Allen, St. George, Walter R. Ellett, Murray, for defendant and respondent.


Appeal from a district court award of attorney's fees in a receivership matter, for resisting an appeal in a prior case involving the same parties. Affirmed with costs to Hydroponics.

Dawson contends our failure to award attorney's fees on appeal in the prior case was an exercise of discretion such as to preclude the trial court from awarding such fees.

Costs are statutory and the award of attorney's fees is contractual — or statutory, — if, in a given case they are awardable by statute. Such fees are not awardable as costs, since they are not included in our statute as such.

The fees awarded by the trial court here, were legitimate expenses of the receivership, — as much so as fees for filing, compensating the receiver, storage of assets, drayage charges, accountant's fees or coffeebreak exhaustion time, — and the like, — all adjunct to the administration of a first or second class receivership.

ELLETT, CROCKETT, TUCKETT and MAUGHAN, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

Alexander Dawson, Inc. v. Hydroponics, Inc.

Supreme Court of Utah
May 28, 1975
535 P.2d 1251 (Utah 1975)
Case details for

Alexander Dawson, Inc. v. Hydroponics, Inc.

Case Details

Full title:ALEXANDER DAWSON, INC., A CORPORATION, PLAINTIFF AND APPELLANT, v…

Court:Supreme Court of Utah

Date published: May 28, 1975

Citations

535 P.2d 1251 (Utah 1975)

Citing Cases

World Peace Movement v. Newspaper Agency

over, we have consistently refused to affirm attorney fee awards to any extent greater than the parties have…

INTERLAKE CO. v. VON HAKE

Consequently, under Rule 66, the order denying receivership costs was well within the discretion of the trial…